Topper Copies

Examine the validity of Arrow's Impossibility Theorem in the light of its criticisms.

Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023

Arrow gave 5 conditions for developing a reasonable democratic Social welfare function, and himself showed how these conditions were not possible to be followed together.

Arrow's five conditions 1. Transitivity: Implied Rational Choice 2. Sensitive to Individual Choices 3. Should be Non Discriminatory 4. Should be Non Dictatorial, and thus be democratically decided 5. Be independent of irrelevant variables.

Arrow's Impossibility Theorem Arrow showed, using Agenda Manipulation, that these 5 conditions cannot be satisfied simultaneously.

Proof: Consider 3 individuals A, B, C who order 3 social states X, Y, Z as shown below.

| | A | B | C | |---|---|---|---| | X | 1 | 2 | 3 | | Y | 3 | 1 | 2 | | Z | 2 | 3 | 1 |

It is clear that X is preferred to Z. At the same time Z is preferred over Y & Y is preferred over X. Thus there is a loss of Transitivity.

Also, in a case where two individuals A & B rank X, Y, Z as A => X>Y>Z & B => Y>Z>X, it is possible that 'Z' is an irrelevant variable which will cause Y to be preferred over X, which would otherwise be indifferent.

Criticisms 1. Amartya Sen criticises AIT on the grounds that it results due to information asymmetry. 2. AK Sen also says if a sufficiently large sample set is taken, then averages dominate outliers.

Therefore, AK Sen converted AIT into a possibility, and showed how the democratic process empowers participants. Arrow's Impossibility therefore remains irrelevant in today's digital era of information.