What happens if LM is vertical, in case of fiscal and monetary expansion. How will your answer change if LM is standard but IS is vertical.
Nesrin P Fasim, AIR 703, 2024
IS-LM curves approach was a Neo-Keynerian idea.
Cases:
(1) When LM is vertical:
Monetary Expansion | Fiscal expansion [diagram: left, a vertical LM curve shifting right to LM1 along IS1, interest rate falling from r1 to r2 as output rises from Y1 to Y2; right, IS curve shifting right from IS1 to IS2 along a flat LM, interest rate rising from r1 to r2 with output fixed at Y1]
-> Interest rate decreases -> can lead to investment↑ and output↑ -> better transmission mechanism -> Interest rate increases -> leads to 'zero crowding out' -> output remains the same
A vertical LM hence has:- -> Monetary policy is effective -> Fiscal policy is ineffective
(2) LM is standard & IS is vertical
Monetary expansion | Fiscal expansion [diagram: left, an upward-sloping IS curve with LM shifting right to LM1, interest rate falling from r1 to r2, output constant at Y; right, a vertical IS shifting right to IS1 along an upward-sloping LM, interest rate rising from r1 to r2, output rising from Y1 to Y2]
-> Interest rate will decrease -> output remaining the same -> No transmission mechanism -> Interest rate increases -> Output increases.
A vertical IS hence indicates: -> monetary policy is not effective -> but crowding out can happen. -> Fiscal policy is effective.