Topper Copies

Explain the different concepts of excess capacity, highlighting differences between Chamberlin and Robinson.

Nesrin P Fasim, AIR 703, 2024

Excess capacity arises in a monopolistic competition, mainly due to brand differentiation and differentiated products.

Normal excess capacity:

[diagram: monopolistic competition equilibrium graph with AR, MR, AC and MC curves tangent at the equilibrium, Q and Qoptimum marked on the output axis]

excess capacity is normal case where; difference in quantity between original quantity and optimum quantity (minimum of AC).

Chamberlain refuted this idea and said that such as excess capacity is not true because production at minimum point of AC is possible in perfect competition, which is not a real life situation.

He said that excess capacity can arise due to price competition in the market.

[diagram Fig(1): AR proportional, AR perceived and MR perceived curves crossing MC and AC curves, with equilibrium points A and E and output Q marked] [diagram Fig(2): AR proportional and LAC curve with Qopt and Q marked, bracketed as excess capacity]

Fig 1: Here the equilibrium is at A, and price at E, where MR=MC at ARperceived = AR proportional.

The excess capacity can be explained through fig (2), where on, the ARperceived become redundant and ARproportional is what matters. At E, if price increases to P1, then the firm can earn supernormal profit, as a result, more firms enters and ARproportional shifts to left and reaches at equilibrium where the AC curve at point F. So, to Chamberlain Qopt Q was excess capacity.

Joan Robinson's excess capacity: => She believed that excess capacity can only occur in the short run.

[diagram: SAC, LAC, MC and AR/MR curves with a shaded supernormal profit region between P, D, F and C, and points E, Qoptimum marked, labelled Joan Robinson's excess capacity]

According to her, the excess capacity is only there in the short run and not applicable at long run, i.e., diff also at minimum point of SAC and point F's quantity (equilibrium point)

Brief differences between these two models:

| Chamberlain | Joan Robinson | |---|---| | Assumptions of symmetricity and uniformity. | No such assumptions. | | Equilibrium point where AR proportional is also equal to AR perceived at MC=MR equilibrium | Equilibrium at marginal cost = marginal revenue in short run only. | | Excess capacity due to price competition only | Due to short run conditions only. | | No much changes. | Later changed by followers to be at long run |

These theories led to an explanation of excess capacity at a different perspective and was a breakthrough in the theory of monopolistic competition.