Explain two tier pricing in monopoly discrimination.
Nesrin P Fasim, AIR 703, 2024
Monopoly price discrimination (PD) refers to charging different prices to different consumers for same commodities.
Types of monopoly discrimination
Two tier Pricing
=> It is a type of pricing in the second degree price discrimination wherein there will be two different consumers and the monopolist charges differently along with an entry price.
[diagram: price/AR graph with entry fee shown as a shaded triangle above the price line; AR1 is the demand curve of the rich consumer, AR2 is the demand curve of the poor consumer, with Q1 and Q2 marked on the output axis]
In this case, entry fee is extracted from the consumers and along with that, a user fee is also incurred.
In case of a price increase:
[diagram: price/AR graph from origin A; AR1 is the large consumer's AR curve, AR2 is the small consumer's AR curve, with P1 and P1' marked on the price axis, E1 and E2 the equilibrium points, and Q1, Q1', Q2, Q2' marked on the output axis]
In case of first case, the monopolist charges A E1 P1 from both consumers and get 2 A E1 P1
As entry fee and profit => Ci's principle
Suppose price increases to P2, the other normal principle operates where (P-MC)Q1
| From Consumer 1 | From Consumer 2 | |---|---| | Ci: X+Y+Z (at Q1 output) | Ci: X+Y+Z (at Q2 output) | | Otherwise: X+Y -> Z is lost (at Q1' output) | Otherwise => X+Y+Z+V (At Q2' output) => V is gain |
In this case, the monopolist will employ 2 tier pricing if the value of V is greater than of Z.
i.e., the gain should be greater than Z from charging a higher price.
Another dimension is that if the smaller consumer's AR curve is very small, the monopolist can exclude them by charging a higher price.
[diagram: price/output graph with P1 and a small entry fee marked near P, AR1 and AR2 demand curves, an arrow labelled price increased pointing to the higher AR2 price level]
At P1 -> excludes the 2nd consumer.