What is Scitovsky solution, explain the entire context.
Nesrin P Fasim, AIR 703, 2024
Scitovsky's solution or Double criterion theory of welfare was formulated as a reaction to the ineffectiveness of Kaldor-Hicks compensation criterion, in some situation.
Scitovsky's criticism of Kaldor-Hicks compensation criterion:
[diagram: utility possibility frontier with utility of B on the vertical axis and utility of A on the horizontal axis; two curves from a common origin region, points C and F on the outer curve, D and E on an inner curve, with K and B marked on the horizontal axis]
According to Kaldor-Hicks criterion, when moving from C to D, there can be movement from D to F such that the utility increase of A can compensate the utility decrease in B such that both are better off even after compensation. Accordingly this only should ideally happen. But Scitovsky pointed out that the reverse is also possible, i.e., on moving from a point D to C, then the person B can compensate person A by such that they both can move to a point E such that A is still better off than earlier point D and both are better off.
Scitovsky said that this is a violation of the compensation criterion and he formulated his own theory of double criterion:
[diagram: two utility possibility frontiers with utility of B on the vertical axis and utility of A on the horizontal axis; the inner frontier through points C and D, the outer through R, with points Y and Q marked on the horizontal axis]
In this situation, all other points in the XY is lesser compared to the policy space of PQ, such that an optimum solution can be reached. In this case R is superior to any other point on policy space in the Utility Possibility Frontier XY in PQ.
Both these evolved as a counter theory to Pareto criterion of welfare.