Topper Copies

"Prices can be over and above MC only in Monopoly market structure". Analyse the statement.

Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023

Under Perfect Competition, a firm faces an infinitely elastic demand curve and is in equilibrium at MR=MC=P. While in monopoly a firm faces a downward sloping AR curve and can set prices above MC=MR.

Relationship between price & MC Under equilibrium conditions, a firm equates MR & MC. The relationship between AR & MR is given by AR = MR(1 - 1/Ep) => Price = Marginal Cost x (1 - 1/Ep) where Ep is the absolute price elasticity of Demand.

Equilibrium under perfect competition Short Run: Even in the short run a perfectly competitive firm equates Price and Marginal Cost, despite earning Economic Profit. [a diagram: MC/Price/AR axis vs Quantity, showing SMC and SAC curves with the MR=P line intersecting SMC at Qe]

Long Run: In the long run, entry of firms lowers prices & increases supply, but the firm still equates Price & Marginal Cost. This is because Ep tends to infinity. [a diagram: Price/AR/MR axis vs Quantity, showing LMC and LAC curves with the MR=P line tangent to LAC]

Monopoly equilibrium Under Monopoly, the firm equates MR & Marginal Cost, but charges a price much higher than MC, at Pc, which is even higher than Average Costs. Thus the firm makes economic profit. This is because Price Elasticity of Demand (Ep) is some positive quantity: P = MC x (1 - 1/Ep) => P > MC. [a diagram: Price/AR/MC axis vs Quantity, showing a downward-sloping AR curve, an MR curve and an MC curve, with Pe, ACe and MC=MR marked at Qe]

Welfare implications When Price = Marginal Cost, the Product is distributed efficiently and there is no Dead Weight Loss. In Monopoly, however, Price>MC, and thus there is a significant Dead Weight Loss of both Consumer & Producer Surplus. The best way to remove, or at least control, Dead Weight Loss is regulation of monopolies by fixing Price not above MC=AC.