Topper Copies

How is Rostow's stages of growth different from Marxian stages of growth?

R Sri Rusat, AIR 52, 2024

Marxian stages of growth is based on "Theory of dialectical mercantilism" which is an economic interpretation of history whereas Rostow's stages of growth depends on the gradual development of traditional economy to higher level of mass consumption economy.

Marxian stages of growth Following 5 stages of growth:

1. Primitive economy - (a) Barter trade takes place between the economy. - (b) The society has relatively no inequalities. - (c) Subsistence level of production and consumption in the economy. 2. Slave economy - (a) Owing to the control of public resources by few over the others leads to development of few versus the underdevelopment of others. - (b) The slaves here supply free labour to the masters and in return get subsistence wage in the form of grains or other essentials. - (c) Gradually, the upper class depending on the level of wealth become classified amongst themselves. - (d) Few become business persons, others become artisans and remaining supply of agriculture labour -> leading to formation of bourgeoisie and labour class. 3. Feudal economy - (a) From the ruins of slave economy, feudal economy develops sophisticated classification of people based on occupation. - (b) The lower class experience lower wage for higher labour supply and the higher class experience higher wages for the lower labour supply. - (c) The above leads to the conflict between bourgeoisie and others, rural and urban inhabitants etc. 4. Capitalistic economy - (a) In this stage, there is no restriction of production technology and mode of production. - (b) Depending upon the ability of merchant class and other market participants proportionate rewards are reaped. - (c) However, the lower rung of society is still underdeveloped which again leads to conflicts. 5. Socialistic economy - Dictatorship of proletariat class and the wages are depended upon the "ability and adequacy of persons" in the economy.

Rostow stages of growth 1. Traditional economy - (a) Based on Pre-newtonian technology. - (b) There are tools available in the economy but the people lack sufficient ability to utilise them. - (c) Once the ability is developed then the surplus is created leading to "Pre-conditions of take off". 2. Pre-conditions to take off - (a) Higher growth rate of saving is maintained - 10%-15% per annum. - (b) Higher growth rate of economy - in double digits. - (c) Higher level of physical investment and intellectual capital. 3. Take off - (a) Higher Social Overhead Capital (i.e) civic amenities is created. - (b) People enjoy better quality of life. - (c) The level of income in their hands goes up. 4. Higher growth maturity - People enjoy higher level of consumption, take up high quality of jobs and the consumption of veblen goods rises. 5. Higher Mass consumption - Prioritises for leisure than for labour leading to higher growth in the service based economy and the research and development takes centre stage.

Criticisms 1. Still the capitalist economy thrives unlike professed by Marx. 2. The stages of growth of Rostow may not be sequentially followed. - Eg: New Zealand and Australia achieved stage IV before stage V. 3. The role of "foreign trade and capital" lacks adequate role in the transformation stages of both Marx and Rostow.