Give a critique of free trade theory in context of developing country experience.
R Sri Rusat, AIR 52, 2024
Free trade theory argues that there must be minimal tariff and non-tariff barriers between the economies to maximise the welfare of both the economies to reach higher standards of development.
[diagram: Fig 1, axes Food (vertical, with Import of food) and cloth (horizontal, with Export of clothes), F1, F2 marked on vertical axis and C1, C2 marked on horizontal axis; a curve from origin, an Isovalue line crossing it at E1 and E2]
In Fig 1, Using Ricardo's comparative advantage of free trade theory we can observe the following: 1. The initial equilibrium at E1, the domestic economy produces at C1 and F1. 2. When the trade is allowed between 2 economies, then the IC shifts from E1 to E2. 3. At E2 point, The domestic economy consumes at C2 and F2. 4. Here, (C2-C1) = Exports of clothes to the foreign economy and (F2-F1) = Import of food in the domestic economy. 5. Therefore, the welfare maximises at E2 then at E1.
Critique of free trade theory 1. National security argument - Certain commodities like defence, cyber technologies etc require appropriate policy control and govt. regulation to prevent their misuse and endangering of national security. 2. Infant Industry Argument - when the developing economy grows at the nascent level of industrial development then during that time opening up of economy would lead to decimation of domestic industries. - Eg: India, During the late 1960s and early 1970s had licensing policy to control the free trade. 3. Job creation Argument - In the developing economies, the Agriculture sector generally has the situation of "disguised unemployment" In order to create better job opportunities in industrial sector, the free trade at the initial stage is restricted. 4. Negative terms of trade - when the developing economy enjoys terms of trade in agriculture sector than in comparison to industries and manufacturing sector this leads to less value exports and more value imports leading to trade deficit in the economy. 5. Trade in critical technologies [diagram: a box "Trade in critical technologies" branching to four labels - Semiconductor, Artificial Intelligence, Modern defense technologies, Quantum technologies] - etc are regulated by the govt. to ensure technology supremacy. - (a) It protects the innovation of the entrepreneurs in the national frontiers. - (b) Misuse of such technology by enemy countries are avoided.
However, free trade theory can be practised in the following circumstances: 1. In case of favourable terms of trade. 2. By forging trade partnerships. - Eg: India UAE CEPA to facilitate better trade. 3. Setting the innovation aside and engaging in other common interests of trade and development.
Thus, Free trade theory has to endure and mitigate the above challenges to maintain balanced trade and development and ensure overall growth and development.