"Marshallian stability ensures Walrasian stability." Do you agree?
Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023
Marshallian Partial Equilibrium Stability is based on Quantity Adjustments while Walrasian Equilibrium is based on Price Adjustments. The Stability of One does not imply the Stability of the Other.
Both stable [a price-quantity diagram with demand and supply curves crossing at Pe, Qe, and P1 marked below and P2 above the equilibrium price]
At P1<Pe, excess demand and thus prices are bid up. At P2>Pe, Excess Supply and thus the price willing to accept is reduced. Thus Walrasian Equilibrium is stable.
At Q1<Qe, the price willing to pay by consumers exceeds the supply price & thus more Quantity is supplied. Similarly at Q2>Qe, Demand Price is less than Supply Price and thus Quantity reduces. Therefore Marshallian Equilibrium is stable.
Marshall stable, Walras unstable [a price-quantity diagram with demand and supply curves crossing at Pe, Qe]
At price above Pe, Excess Demand could lead to bidding up of prices, and thus Walras is unstable. At Q<Qe, Demand Price is greater than Supply Price => Quantity rises. Thus Marshallian is stable.
Walras stable, Marshall unstable [a price-quantity diagram with an upward-sloping demand curve that is steeper than the supply curve]
In this case Demand is upward sloping and is steeper than the Supply curve. Clearly here Marshall is unstable.
The Stability of both equilibria depends on the relative steepness of the Demand & Supply Curves.