Topper Copies

Substitution effect is the deciding factor about the nature of goods. Comment.

Ayush Agrawal, AIR 341, 2023

Substitution Effect is the effect of a relative price change on the Quantity of the commodity purchased. It is always NEGATIVE.

Nature of commodity The nature of commodity is defined on the basis of overall price effect = Substitution Effect + Income Effect.

1. Normal Good: when both Substitution Effect & Income Effect are negative. A decrease in price could increase Quantity of X2 to X3 due to Income effect and from X1 to X2 due to substitution effect. [an indifference-curve and budget-line diagram on money vs quantity of X axes, showing the substitution effect (X1 to X2) and income effect (X2 to X3) for a normal good] 2. Inferior Good: when Income Effect is positive, Price Effect < Substitution Effect, as shown below. [two indifference-curve and budget-line diagrams (Fig 2 and Fig 3) on income vs quantity of X axes, each marking X1, X2, X3] 3. Giffen Good: under this case Income Effect (X1X3) is even greater then Substitution effect (X1X2). Thus a reduction in price reduces Quantity Purchased.

The Nature of Good therefore depends more on relative levels of Income Effect & Substitution Effect, and more so on the direction of the Income Effect, as the Substitution Effect is always negative.