Critically examine H-O model.
R Sri Rusat, AIR 52, 2024
According to Heckscher-Ohlin model, A country facing higher labour intensive production or higher capital intensive production would export that commodity which has factor intensification and imports commodities where it is less factor intensive.
Assumption 1. 2 factors of production - labour and capital. 2. 2 country - Country X and Country Y. 3. Country X uses the labour intensive production technique and Country Y uses the capital intensive production technique. - (i.e) Country X -> K/L < 1 and Country Y -> K/L > 1 4. Incomplete specialisation occurs in both the countries 5. Perfect capital mobility between the factors of production.
Model
I) When the countries use their factor intensive production method [diagram: axes capital (vertical) and Labour (horizontal), origin O; two curves reaching points Ex (above Lx and Kx) and Ey (above L2y and K2)]
- Here the country X produces output using L1X labour and KX capital to produce the optimum level of output whereas country Y produces using L2Y level of labour and K2 level of output. - The respective economies reach their optimal points at E1 and E2 at Autarky prices
II) When the countries engage in trade [diagram: axes capital (vertical) and Labour (horizontal), origin O; two curves meeting at point E*, with K* marked on the capital axis and L* marked on the labour axis]
- When the countries opt for trade then they reach the point E*, with the factor employment of labour at L* and capital at K*. - Country X exports labour intensive commodity and imports capital intensive commodity. - Country Y exports capital intensive commodity and imports labour intensive commodity.
Criticism 1. The role of technology is ignored in the H-O model. 2. The role of foreign investments and foreign capital are neglected. 3. In a real economy, there are more than 2 countries exchanging commodities with each other - complicating the H-O model. 4. The role of Social Overhead Capital and Directly production Activities are ignored.