Topper Copies

Explain trade adjustments and protectionism if one country has advantage due to external economies of scale and first mover advantage.

Manish Sharma, AIR 307, 2023

External economies of scale refer to lowering of cost with time incurred in each production of goods, due to factors such as learning by doing, improvement in overall infra etc. e.g - cost reduction in cars production

External Economies and Trade - Due to external economies, it is possible for a country - A to gain advantage over B even though overall A is less efficient in producing the product. - The advantage occurred because A moved first and established dominance. - Here because A started 1st, it captured world market Dw and sells 400 units at ₹3

[diagram: price vs quantity graph, curves ACA, ACB, demand curves Dd, Dd', Dw, points A', B', C' marked, price points 4, 3, 2.75, 2.5 and quantity points 50, 300, 400, 450, labelled "Fig: 1st Mover advantage"]

- However since B's entry cost is at ₹4, it will never be able to match A even though Avg cost ACB < ACA at all quantities - Hence, protectionism is advocated in this case

Protectionism and Trade Adjustment - The above case result in inefficient production and results in loss of consumer welfare - B could have supplied 450 quantity at ₹2.25 - To protect B, tariff imposition is preferred over domestic market to enable B to reach external economic efficiency - In this case, if the demand curve of domestic is Dd, then B can supply 300 goods locally at ₹2.75 - This results in sufficient protection resulting in B able to compete in global market efficiently

Case of Ineffective Protection - If the domestic demand curve was such that- e.g. price post tariff > world price of A => B won't be able to produce for global market - If Dd' were the local demand curve, then 50 qty is supplied by B at ₹3.75 - Hence any tariff protection is ineffective in this case.

Hence, India has used infant industry protection in our electronics sectors to give boost to our mfg through PLI scheme.