Examine why classical theory couldn't explain paradox of thrift? What were the different assumptions under Keynes that it could be explained? What was its role in explaining great depression.
Vaibhav Rathore, AIR 717, 2023
Classical Economists believed that Savings is a virtue. Because, with higher level of Savings the Supply of Loanable funds will increase & this will lead to a lower interest rate, due to which firms will find it cheaper to borrow & thus investment in the Economy rises leading to higher output & Employment.
[diagram: interest rate vs Loanable fund graph; upward sloping supply curves Lss(S) and Lss' and a downward sloping demand curve Ldd[I+(G-T)]; intersection points marked i1, i2 on the interest rate axis and L1, L2 on the horizontal axis; note beside: interest rate reduces from i1 to i2.]
According to Keynesian Theory, higher Savings would lead to lesser Consumption & hence reduced Aggregate demand in the Economy.
Y = C + S (Income) (Consumption) (Savings)
Also, C = C̄ + cY ; mpc → Marginal Propensity to consume.
⇒ S = Y-C = -C̄ + (1-c)Y ⇒ S = -C̄ + (1-c)Y ; I = Ī
At equilibrium, Y=AD ⇒ C+S = C+I ⇒ I=S → At equilibrium
[diagram: Savings/Investment vs Output graph; horizontal line I (Investment) and horizontal line C̄ below it; upward sloping Savings line crossing the Investment line at output Y1, with Y0 and Y2 also marked on the output axis]
At Y>AD ⇒ S>I ⇒ I has to increase. ∴ Output level falls from Y2 to Y1 and there is a downward movement along Savings line.
At Y<AD ⇒ S<I ⇒ I has to decrease ∴ Output falls below Y0.
Thus, there is an unstable equilibrium at output level Y1, where Investment = Savings.
Paradox of Thrift could explain great depression because they asserted the role of Government expenditure. That is, during the great depression, there was a lesser demand in the Economy, thus the government needs to intervene via fiscal Policy tool by increasing its expenditure such that the Aggregate demand increases and the output increases such that equilibrium output is at full Employment level.
[diagram: 45-degree line diagram; AD vs Y graph with two upward sloping lines AD and AD' parallel to each other, a 45° line from origin, intersecting AD' at point where Y=AD, with Y0 and Yn marked on the output axis]
Initially, Y0 < Yn ∴ Economy is below its full Employment level. The AD is lesser than the expected AD.
∴ With higher G, AD shifts to AD' such that equilibrium output level is Yn.
Criticisms of P.O.T. 1. It didn't considered the role of higher liquidity in the market due to higher Savings. 2. Firms can shifts their Investment based on their future expectations due to higher Liquidity in the Market.