Does government borrowing always crowd out private investments? Analyse.
Vaibhav Rathore, AIR 717, 2023
According to Neo-Keynesian (IS-LM) Model, if the government borrowing increases, then it leads to increase in the government expenditure which shifts the IS curve to IS', the interest rate increases from i1 to i2 and due to higher interest rate, there is a decrease in Investment which leads to a lesser increase in output.
[diagram: interest rate vs output graph, LM curve and two IS curves (IS, IS'), interest rate rising from i1 to i2, output rising from Y1 to Y2 (instead of Y1 to Y1'); adjoining small diagram: interest rate vs investment, showing a "crowding out" bracket between I1 and I2]
Increase in output is Y1Y2 instead of Y1Y1'. This decrease in output (Y2Y1') is due to Crowding out of Private investment.
However, government borrowing need not always Crowd out investment, in fact the following measures could Crowd in the Private Investment.
1. If the government expenditure is on Capital Creation such as development of Sustainable infrastructure such as roads, railways, Port development, etc. This reduces logistical cost, improves connectivity & overall efficiency in the Economy.
2. Focussing on simplified tax rules, lenient environmental Laws, IPR reforms, Labour reforms, etc.
Thus, certain structural reforms if undertaken will improve ease of doing Business & will Crowd in investment despite higher government borrowings.