The Supreme Court of India has upheld unique asymmetry in India's federalism by intricately balancing centralized authority and regional autonomy. Discuss with the help of relevant case laws.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Asymmetric federalism refers to the idea that states are unequal horizontally (wrt each other) and vertically (different relations with centre). Recently, 6th Schedule status of Ladakh has bought it in news.
Role of Supreme Court
1. SR Bommai case (1994) saying that federalism is basic structure 2. Limits on imposition of President rule (Art 356) and making it judicially reviewable 3. Role of governor -> Not agent of Union but its representative, (BP Singhal) case puts limits on pleasure of president 4. Recent Mineral Development Authority case allowing States to charge royalty and bolster finances 5. SC permission to Union for CBI, NIA like central bodies 6. By making speaker's power subject to judicial review (Keisham Meghachandra), with respect to Money bill, it has provided voice to Rajya Sabha 7. J&K reorganisation Act upheld in 2023 allowing Union to change territory and status 8. Jurisprudence of 1970's & 1980 with regard to states balancing direction by Centre in context (eg Railways, Communication)
Way Forward
1. Accomodative Spirit 2. Special focus (Art 19 - Equal protection) 3. Consensus (Inter State Council - Art 262)
India should work by having collaborative federalism where national unity is build on regional autonomy and promoting partnership & unity & diversity.