Explain the quantitative and qualitative methods of credit control. Which one is better for inflation targeting?
Manish Sharma, AIR 307, 2023
The recent monetary tightening through interest rate, aggressive/hawkish tones reflect the usage of quantitative and qualitative methods of credit control.
Credit Control - It refers to instruments used by central banks to limit credit supply in the economy - Generally used to fight inflation, bring macroeconomic stability and orderly economic growth. e.g - raising repo, bank rates - Two types < quantitative, qualitative
Quantitative Credit Control - These refer to direct intervention of central bank to limit money supply and reduce credit demand. - Through these, credit control across all sectors is enforced. - Main instruments used are:- - repo operations - raising repo rate - selling OMOs - sucking durable liquidity - Increasing bank rates - MSS bonds to suck large capital inflows and limit money supply
Qualitative Credit Control - These are persuasive techniques used by central banks to bring credit control. - These involve moral suasion, sectoral credit controls to give signal. example - policy guidance - neutral, tightening, accomodating of RBI MPC - Generally informal channels of comm. - RBI governor talks with banks are used
Use in Inflation Targeting - In inflation targeting, a central bank is explicitly mandated by law to control inflation. - gives primacy to inflation in pursuance of other objectives - growth, forex - RBI Act 2016 mandated RBI to have (4±2)% inflation targeting goal in medium term
Benefits of Quantitative - Brings explicit reduction in credit growth => money supply falling => WACR (call rate) and medium term interest rate above inflation => positive real interest rate - Provides the path for inflation attainment - Also, enables rule based policy making => low time inconsistency problem - General market mechanism through broad guidance => low chances of credit allocative inefficiency
Benefits of Qualitative - Works with the aim of minimal market disturbance - Don't need a sledge hammer (quantitative) where needle suffices - helps avoid knee jerk reaction
Hence, in times of high deviation from target - quantitative should be used whereas once near target more thrust on qualitative method to reach the target.