Topper Copies

"Monetarists and Classicals draw same conclusions in both short run as well as long run." Analyse.

Vaibhav Rathore, AIR 717, 2023

Monetarism is also referred to as Neo-classical Model or Friedman Phelps Fooling Model. As the name Suggests, the agents can be fooled in a short run through fiscal or Monetary changes.

Case of Increase in Money supply (In case of Monetarism)

[diagram: top graph, Price(P) on vertical axis and Output(Y) on horizontal axis; upward sloping AS curve; two upward sloping AD curves, AD and AD', with AD' to the right of AD; Price rises from P1 to P2, Output rises from Yn to Yn'; bottom graph, interest rate on vertical axis and Output(Y) on horizontal axis; downward sloping IS curve and upward sloping LM(M/P) curve shifting rightwards and downwards to LM'; interest rate falls from i1 to i2; both graphs labelled "Short Run"]

In case of an increase in Money Supply (Mss) the AD curve shifts rightwards, and LM curve shifts rightwards & downwards. However, shift in the LM is lesser as Price is also increasing which restricts real Money Supply.

∴ In short Run, in case of increase in Mss, Price rises from P1 to P2, output rises from Yn to Yn' and interest rate decreases from i1 to i2.

[diagram: top graph, Price(P3, P1) vs Output; three upward sloping AS curves (AS, AS', AS'') and two AD curves (AD, AD'); Price rises to P3, Output returns from Yn' to Yn; bottom graph, interest rate vs Output; IS curve and two LM curves (LM, LM'); both graphs labelled "Long Run"]

However, in Long Run the workers will revise their expectations based on higher Price in the Market. ∴ They will keep shifting the AS curve upwards till AS intersects AD at Yn level of output. Also, LM will shift upwards as the Money Supply decreases due to increase in Price.

This will continue till IS intersects LM again at Yn level of output.

Thus, in Long Run Monetary Policy is Ineffective.

Clearly, it can be seen that Monetarists gives similar result as that of Classical only in the Long Run. While, in short run they behaves similar to Keynesian.