How did Kalecki utilize Lerner's Index of Monopoly power in his theory of distribution? Examine the conclusions drawn by his theory.
Vaibhav Rathore, AIR 717, 2023
Kalecki's Model
Assumptions:- 1. Kalecki considered the Entrepreneurs & higher end workers such as CEO, CFO, CTO, worker's working at higher Managerial Posts under his definition of Capitalists. 2. Considered Lerner's Index as a determinant of Monopoly Power.
μ̄ = (P-MC)/P ⇒ μ.P = (P-MC) Here, MC=AC ⇒ μ.P = (P-AC) → Per unit Profit of Monopolist. ⇒ μ.P.X = (P-AC).X → Total Profit of Monopolist. ⇒ Σμ.P.X → Profit of all the Monopolist's in the Market ΣP.X → Turnover in the Market
⇒ μ̄ = Σμ.P.X/ΣP.X = Σ(P-AC).X/ΣP.X
Replace, ΣP.X = T ⇒ μ̄ = Σ(P-AC)X/T ...(1)
Also, Output/Income (Y) = Wage(W) + Profit(P) ⇒ μ̄ = P/T = (Y-W)/T
On solving, ⇒ (ΣW/Y) = 1/(1 + μ̄.T/W) ...(2) → (Wage share equation)
Kalecki used the above equation for explaining Constant (W/Y) ratio in 20th Century.
According to Kalecki, the Product of μ̄ & T remained Constant which kept (W/Y) consistent.
The Constant (μ̄.T) is attributed to the following factors:-
1. Before World War :- μ̄ was high due to restrictions of entry in the market & thus higher Monopoly. T was low due to lower cost of Raw Material in agriculture ⇒ μ̄.T = constant.
2. After World War :- μ̄ decreased due to free entry of the firms. T increased due to higher Price of raw materials ⇒ μ̄.T = Constant.
3. Business cycle → Boom: μ̄ = Low, T = high (due to higher inflation) ⇒ μ̄.T = Constant Recession: μ̄ = High, T = Low (Lower inflation) ⇒ μ̄.T = constant
Criticisms of Kalecki's Model 1. Did not considered the effect of Trade Union. 2. Price differential is not only due to Monopoly Power, it can be due to other factors such as efficiency of firms. 3. Monopoly Power is not dependent only on Lerner's Index (i.e. P>MC). It also depends on Natural Monopoly, IPR Regime, Legal Laws in the Country, etc. 4. Kalecki's Model does not works in case of developing Nations. (Weak Empirical Evidence)