Examine how the profit, wage and rent in Ricardian system move differently with the movements in the level of income.
Vaibhav Rathore, AIR 717, 2023
Assumptions of Ricardian Model 1. Rent is defined as the difference between Average Productivity of Labour (APL) & Marginal Productivity of Labour (MPL). ⇒ Rent = APL - MPL
2. Both APL & MPL are downward sloping with MPL steeper than APL. 3. Profit = Capital accumulation by Monopolist. 4. Only 2 sectors are considered - Agriculture (More Prominent) & Industry.
[diagram: graph with vertical axis APL, MPL and horizontal axis Labour; two downward sloping curves, APL and the steeper MPL, points A, B, B', C, C', D, E, O marked on the curves and axes; a reservation wage rate W1 marked, with a hatched region labelled Profit between the wage line and the curves; labour levels L1, L2 marked on the horizontal axis; note beside the diagram: The fall in MPL is steeper than APL ⇒ Rent rises with rise in Labour force.]
The reservation wage (W1) is determined by Social & cultural factors.
There is no movement of capital from one sector to another & to ensure this, the share of Labour remains constant in Both the sectors.
Initial level of Employment in the Economy is L1. ⇒ Rent = (APL-MPL) x OL1, ⇒ ABC region represents Rent.
Wage = W1 ⇒ Total wage Bill of Capitalist = OW1 x OL1, ⇒ OL1DE region represents Wage.
The region ACDE represents Profit of the Capitalist.
Now, with expansion in the Economy, the level of Employment in the Economy rises. Let us consider a Situation when Employment = OL2. ⇒ Rent = (APL-MPL) x OL2 = Region BB'C'C, representing Rent at L2 level of Employment.
Wage Bill of Capitalist = OW1 x OL2 = Region OEC'L2 Profit of Capitalist = Region CC'D
∴ It can be clearly observed that with expansion of Economy, that is with rise in the Employment level in the Economy, the Rent & Wage rises while the Profit reduces, which is Counter intuitive.
Criticisms of Ricardian Model 1. Weak Empirical Evidence. Because, Profit rises with expansion of the Economy. 2. Role of technology is not considered, due to which APL & MPL can rise alone which can lead to increase in the Profit.