Explain the difference between Cournot model of duopoly with similar product and differentiated product.
Vaibhav Rathore, AIR 717, 2023
Cournot Model with Similar Product
Assumptions:- 1) Homogenous Product. 2) Simultaneous Quantity setting in the Market. ⇒ P = A - B(Q1+Q2) = A - BQ. 3) Marginal Cost = Constant (C); Fixed Cost = 0 (FC) 4) 2 firms in the Market.
⇒ π1 = P.Q1 - C.Q1 = (A-BQ).Q1 - C.Q1 ⇒ π1 = AQ1 - [B(Q1+Q2)]Q1 - CQ1 ⇒ π1 = AQ1 - BQ1² - BQ1Q2 - CQ1 ⇒ ∂π1/∂Q1 = A - 2BQ1 - BQ2 - C = 0 ⇒ Q1 = (A-C)/2B - Q2/2 ...(1) → B.R. fn of firm 1.
Similarly, using Symmetricity, ∂π2/∂Q2 = 0 ⇒ Q2 = (A-C)/2B - Q1/2 ...(2) → B.R. fn of firm 2.
Solving for (1) & (2) we get, (Q1,Q2) = ((A-C)/3B, (A-C)/3B)
⇒ Q = Q1+Q2 = (2/3)(A-C)/B 2/3rd of the extent of Market.
⇒ π1 = [A - B.(2/3)((A-C)/B)] . (A-C)/3B - C.((A-C)/3B) = ((A+2C-C)/3) . ((A-C)/3B) = (A-C)²/9B ; π2 = (A-C)²/9B.
Cournot Model with differentiated Product
↳ Differentiated Product ; close Substitutes. ↳ MC=0 ; FC=0 ⇒ T.C=0 P1 = a1 - Q1 - Q2/2 . { a1,a2 → Attributes of firm (1) & (2) respectively. P2 = a2 - Q2 - Q1/2
π1 = P1Q1 = a1Q1 - Q1² - Q1Q2/2 ⇒ ∂π1/∂Q1 = a1 - 2Q1 - Q2/2 = 0 ⇒ Q1 = a1/2 - Q2/4 ...(3) → B.R. fn of firm (1)
π2 = P2Q2 = a2Q2 - Q2² - Q1Q2/2. ⇒ ∂π2/∂Q2 = 0 ⇒ a2 - 2Q2 - Q1/2 = 0 ⇒ Q2 = a2/2 - Q1/4 ...(4) → BR fn of firm (2)
Solving for Equation (3) & (4). ⇒ Q1 = a1/2 - (1/4)[a2/2 - Q1/4] ⇒ Q1 = a1/2 - a2/8 + Q1/16. ⇒ (15/16)Q1 = a1/2 - a2/8 ⇒ Q1 = (8/15)[a1 - a2/4]
Similarly, Q2 = (8/15)[a2 - a1/4]
Thus, in case of Cournot Model with Similar Product, both the firms produces same level of output & their Profits is also same. (Q1=Q2=Q/2) & (π1=π2=π/2)
However, in case of differentiated Product, both the firms will be producing different level of Output & also, their Profits will be different due to difference in their attributes. [Q1≠Q2 & π1≠π2].