How does per unit subsidy create dead weight loss? Do you think a direct subsidy is better?
Manish Sharma, AIR 307, 2023
Dead weight loss is the overall loss of welfare resulting due to economic and policy inefficiencies. - distorbs optimum economic resource allocation, production or consumption
Subsidy and Dead Weight loss - A subsidy is a tax rebate or incentive given to producer/consumer - If a unit subsidy of AB is given => supply curve shifts from SS -> SS'
[diagram: price vs output graph, demand curve D, supply curves S and S' (per unit subsidy), intersecting at points E, F, B, G, labelled "Fig: Dead weight loss due to unit subsidy"]
- Hence, the equilib changes from E to G (OP,OQ) to (OP',OQ') - Total subsidy = PP'GF - Gain in welfare = PP'GE - Hence, EFG is the dead weight loss due to unit subsidy.
Reasons - The subsidy for say product X, resulted in its extra consumption wrt other products say Y (no subsidy) - Hence, there was distortion in overall consumption pattern => dead weight loss
Is direct subsidy better - In direct subsidy, direct monetary incentive is given, without any market-price distortion between products. - It results in better consumer welfare since consumer have more choices on how to spend raised income
[diagram: indifference curve graph, Good X on x-axis, curves IC1, IC2, IC3, budget lines from K/M to N/L/N', points E, G, H, Z marked, labelled "Fig: Direct vs indirect subsidy"]
- In fig, the indirect subsidy shifts consumption curve from MN -> MN' (Px falling) - This results in rise in welfare from IC1 -> IC2 - However, through compensating variation, the same improvement would have been reached if prices of both were changed keeping proportion same - however the subsidy used would have been less NL as against NN' - Also, direct income subsidy of NN' would result in IC3 indiff curve instead of just IC2
Hence, economically direct subsidy is better than indirect subsidy. However indirect given due to:- - Increase specific production - wheat, rice in 1960s - inflation relief - diesel, petrol - bring change in consumption patterns - direct money used in buying alcohol
However, direct subsidy also has its issues:- - It distorts leisure-income dynamics - may result in less work
Hence, depending upon objective, cost-benefit, it should be decided which type of subsidy should be given