"Marshallian stability ensures Walrasian stability." Do you agree?
Vaibhav Rathore, AIR 717, 2023
Marshallian Equilibrium is Quantity determined. That is, According to Marshall Equilibrium is determined based on the willingness to pay of a consumer for a given level of Quantity & willingness to sell of a Producer of the given Quantity. Whereas, Walrasian Equilibrium is Price determined.
In case of normal market conditions, that is, when Supply curve is upward sloping & Demand curve is downward sloping, Marshallian & Walrasian results are same & there exists stable equilibrium. Similarly, when demand curve is upward sloping & supply curve is downward sloping, both Marshall & Walras exhibits unstable equilibrium. However, when both demand & supply curve are sloping in the same direction with different elasticities, Marshall & Walras gives opposite results.
| Situation | Marshall | Walras | |---|---|---| | DD & SS curves are upward sloping with DD steeper than SS curve | Unstable | Stable | | DD & SS curves upward sloping, SS steeper than DD | Stable | Unstable | | DD & SS curve downward sloping, DD steeper than SS | Stable | Unstable | | DD & SS curve downward sloping, SS steeper than DD | Unstable | Stable |
Note:- DD → Demand curve; SS → Supply curve.
Case-I:- Both DD & SS are upward sloping with DD steeper than SS.
[diagram: Price-Quantity graph with upward sloping DD (steeper) and SS lines, points D0,S0 at price P1/quantity Q0 and D2,S2 at quantity Q1,Q2; note beside it: At Q2>Q1, D2>S2 ⇒ Quantity traded will rise ⇒ unstable equilibrium; boxed label "Marshallian Equilibrium"]
[diagram: Price-Quantity graph with upward sloping DD and SS lines, prices P0,P1,P2 marked, quantity Q1 marked; note beside it: At Price, P2>P1 ⇒ excess supply ⇒ Price falls ⇒ stable equilibrium; boxed label "Walrasian Equilibrium"]
Hence, Marshallian stability need not always ensure Walrasian stability.