Topper Copies

Substitution effect is the deciding factor about the nature of goods. Comment.

Vaibhav Rathore, AIR 717, 2023

Substitution effect is used in the context of 2 Commodities world. Let say there are 2 commodities X & Y & if the Price of commodity X is changed keeping the Price of Y as constant, then there will be a change in demand of Commodity Y due to change in the Price ratio Px/Py. This situation reflects the Substitution Effect.

However, Substitution effect (S.E.) is always negative irrespective of the type of commodity. The negative S.E. represents an inverse relation between Price & Output.

Infact, it is the Income Effect (I.E.) which is the deciding factor about the nature of goods.

- In case of Normal goods, both I.E. & S.E. are negative, leading to overall negative Price effect (P.E.). - In case of Inferior goods (not Giffen), I.E. is Positive, while S.E. is negative. But, S.E. dominates I.E., so P.E. is negative. - In case of Giffen goods, I.E. is Positive & it dominates negative S.E. leading to a Positive P.E.

Thus, I.E. determines the nature of commodity rather than the S.E. which is always negative irrespective of the type of commodity.