Explain the differences between Kaldor's and Kalecki's model of distribution.
Manish Sharma, AIR 307, 2023
Kaldor and Kalecki models try to explain the distribution of factors of production - wages, profits etc in the economy
| Kaldor's model | Kalecki's model | |---|---| | Based on Keynesian analysis of economy | Uses monopoly power of firms in determining distribution | | All wages- salary, non-salary taken together - as workers | Salaried class wage taken under portion of firms. Only laborer's wages taken as wages. | | Key Assumptions: savings = Investment; Sp > Sw where Sp = mps of profits enterprises, Sw = mps of workers | Key assumptions: MC = AC; monopoly power by lerner's index (u) | | Key outcome: P/Y = 1/Y . 1/(Sp-Sw) - Sw/(Sp-Sw), where P/Y is share of profits in Economy, I is investment | Key outcome: W/A = 1/(H.u . T/W), where W/A is share of labor, u is overall monopoly, T is Turnover | | Hence, level of investment determine the share of profit and workers | The level of overall monopoly power of firms and aggregate turnover decide ratio of worker wages | | Explained the rise of share of profits during inflationary times and fall during recession | Explained why workers share has remained constant since WW II: u increased; Turnover decreased due to falling raw material cost | | Assumptions are less restrictive | Highly restrictive assumptions: ignored power of union all together; Treating salaried & non-salaried differently | | General equilib. analysis in nature | |
Hence, Kaldor's analysis was an improvement over Kalecki's.