Topper Copies

Despite having features borrowed from Constitutions of various other countries, the Constitution of India remains unique. Discuss. (Answer in 200 words)

Sudipa Dutta, AIR 41, 2025

B R Ambedkar proudly said in a Constituent Assembly meeting that "India has formed its constitution by ransacking almost all the known constitutions of the world." This statement of B R Ambedkar, 'the father of Indian Constitution' aptly describes the formation of Indian Constitution.

Borrowed features from 1. Government of India Act, 1935 -> federal features, bicameralism, Union, state & concurrent List 2. British Constitution -> Parliamentary form of government, rule of law, single citizenship 3. American Constitution -> Fundamental rights, judicial review, independence of judiciary 4. Soviet Constitution -> Fundamental duties and the ideals of justice in the preamble

Uniqueness of Indian Constitution can be determined by following factors 1. Appropriate modification to suit Indian Interests -> such as republic form of government. 2. Incorporates Gandhian Ideals -> in the form of Directive principles of state policy. 3. Rationalised provisions which reflect over traditional customs -> such as fundamental duties incorporating our moral values. 4. Lengthiest constitution -> due to simplified and detailed provisions. 5. Neither follows British principle of Parliamentary sovereignty nor follows American principle of judicial supremacy

Conclusion Uniqueness of Indian Constitution can be determined by the test of time it has faced and still stood straight for 75 long years.