Topper Copies

The basic structure doctrine of the Indian Constitution is a judicial innovation. Analyse. (Answer in 200 words)

Sudipa Dutta, AIR 41, 2025

The basic structure doctrine of the Indian Constitution was propounded in Keshvananda Bharati Case (1973).

Components of this doctrine 1. Federalism 2. Rule of law 3. Secularism 4. Judicial Review 5. Equality

Whether it is a judicial innovation.

Arguments for 1. The doctrine of basic structure was established by Supreme Court in response to Parliament's 24th Amendment Act of 1971 & 25th Amendment Act of 1971. 2. The judiciary tried to uphold the primacy of Constitution by passing this doctrine. 3. This doctrine has given ultimate power to judiciary for determining the constitutionality of a law. 4. Judiciary has conferred upon itself the prime responsibility of interpretation of constitution through this doctrine

Arguments against 1. The Parliament's power to amend the constitution is not absolute as our founding fathers had envisaged. 2. The Judiciary has only upheld this principle. 3. The doctrine of basic structure of Indian Constitution was to balance Parliament's amending power and constitutional supremacy. 4. Judiciary has no role in innovating this doctrine as it was always present only that judiciary has made it apparent through formal acknowledgement.

Conclusion The basic structure of Indian Constitution is a unique feature of our Constitution which was made available through judiciary's efforts and it sure had a role to play in its popularity.