The Indian Railways (IR) has approximately 43,000 hectares of vacant land, which is not required for operational purposes in the foreseeable future. Such plots of land are entrusted to the Rail Land Development Authority (RLDA) by the Railway Board for commercial development. As the Vice-Chairman of the RLDA, you are responsible for identifying the potential of these vacant lands and work out the best mode of commercial development. Meanwhile, the Union government is planning to build India's first intermodal stations. Intermodal Stations (IMS) are terminal infrastructure, which integrate various transportation modes such as rail, road, mass rapid transit system, bus rapid transit, inland waterways, auto-rickshaws, taxis and private vehicles so that people can move from one mode to another seamlessly. The Union Ministry has shortlisted two cities to build IMS. The land identified in one city, which also happens to be the home town of a Union Minister, belongs to the RLDA. You are supposed to clear a final report on this land based on which it will be cleared for building IMS. After going through the land details, you discover that the land contains natural urban forest with more than 40,000 trees that provide diverse ecosystem services to the residents of the cities. Clearing this land for the project will lead to cutting of these trees. Also, the news of this land being under consideration is already out and the environmental civil society groups in the city are protesting against it. They are threatening to go to the court if the trees are cut to proceed with the project. Further, an alternative site has been proposed by an environmental think tank, which could be suitable in terms of sustainable development of the project. On the other hand, there is pressure from the Union Minister to clear the land for the project. A senior member from the Railway Board has also approached you to look into the issue favourably else it might upset the political executive. (a) What are the ethical dilemmas faced by you in the given situation? (b) Under the given conditions, what are the options available to you? (c) Critically evaluate each of the options listed by you. (d) What option would you adopt and why? (Answer in 250 words)
Sudipa Dutta, AIR 41, 2025
The given case is a classic example of environmental sustainability being jeopardized by economic development.
Stakeholder
a) Ethical dilemmas
1. Commercial development vs Environmental protection 2. Personal virtue ethics vs senior instructions 3. Environmental ethics vs Professional ethics 4. Short term gain vs long term pain 5. Anthropocentrism vs eco-centrism
b) Options available
1. Option 1 => Clear the land for IMS to be built 2. Option 2 => Ask the minister to give the orders in writing 3. Option 3 => Do not clear the land and media briefing on the same 4. Option 4 => persuade the minister.
c) Evaluation of options
1. Option 1 - Merit: adhering to duty; fast development of IMS - Demerit: environmental degradation; false sense of duty completion.
2. Option 2 - Merit: senior orders in writing - Demerit: not a sustainable solution; core issue not addressed.
3. Option 3 - Merit: environment protected; civil society and media engaged - Demerit: delays in IMS development; not a holistic solution; sensationalization of issues
4. Option 4 - Merit: fulfill duty with integrity; fulfill deontological ethics - Demerit: minister may not agree; superficial solution
d) My course of action
I will take option 4 with slight modifications.
1. I will engage civil society and minister to have a discussion. Reasons -> in line with good governance ethics of community participation 2. I will persuade the minister about the benefits of sanctioning alternative land. Reasons -> in line with professional ethics 3. I will make the minister understand the threat to his reputation as well as to the environment. Reasons -> in line with environmental ethics
Therefore, the issue of environmental sustainability should be based on sustainable development.