Topper Copies

Laws promote social control by resolving basic value conflicts, settling individual disputes, and making rules that even our rulers must follow. But, law does not always achieve its purpose and can rather harm society. In this background, discuss the limitations and dysfunctions of law, with examples. (Answer in 150 words)

Sudipa Dutta, AIR 41, 2025

Laws are set of rules, regulations and guidelines that guide individual behaviour in a society. "Laws are not needed when citizens are abiding." -> Aristotle.

Limitations and dysfunctions of law

1. Not proportional -> does not apply proportionally to all individuals. Eg -> decriminalising of business laws 2. Improper implementation of existing laws Eg -> IPC section 498A used as "dowry terrorism," -> held by Delhi HC. 3. Rational of a law is not discussed with citizens Eg -> the act of internet shutdown without proper public consultation. 4. Ambiguous laws Eg -> what to do when road is jammed, when ambulance is waiting? 5. Are restraining not liberating Eg -> laws against commercial surrogacy hampering right to reproduction.

In order to achieve its purpose, laws need to be encompassing views of all and should be fine mix of ethical egoism and ethical altruism.