Bring out the differences between 'coming together federations' and 'holding together federations' with examples. (Answer in 200 words)
Sudipa Dutta, AIR 41, 2025
Article 1 of our Constitution defines India as a 'Union of State', which means two things: 1. Indian states are not joined by an agreement. 2. No state has the power to secede from the Union.
Therefore, ours is an example of 'holding together federations'.
On the other hand, 'coming together federations' is one which is operational in United States of America. Here 50 states have come together to form a federation after American Revolution (1775)
Major differences between the two 1. Level of autonomy in different - American states have greater autonomy in their working than states of India. 2. Jurisdiction of Judiciary - American judiciary is divided into federal & state judiciary enforcing federal and state Laws respectively. - where as India has an integrated judiciary Enforcing both federal and state laws. 3. Citizenship - American constitution provides for dual citizenship. - where as Indian constitution provides for single citizenship. 4. Single Constitution - Federations of states provides for dual constitution at state and centre level. Eg in America - where as Union of states provides for single constitution for an entire country like India. 5. Powers of Centre and States - In a 'coming together federation' centre cannot override states laws. Eg- America - whereas 'Holding together federation' provides for strong centre with overriding powers over states.
Conclusion Both types of federation is a part of larger principle of 'federalism' which forms a basic feature of constitution and therefore should be taken care of.