In a southern Indian state, a globally renowned high end mobile manufacturing company advertised job vacancies, attracting many hopeful applicants. Among them were two sisters from a nearby village who applied after seeing advertisements on WhatsApp. Upon arrival at the factory's main gate, a security guard met them and asked a series of questions, including an inquiry about their marital status. After confirming that they were married, they were informed that they could not proceed further. No explanation was provided, leaving them confused and disappointed. Back in their village, the sisters reflected on their experience and felt dismayed at being denied an opportunity without a clear reason. Even the auto-rickshaw driver who took them to the facility had hinted that married women might not be hired, yet they still hoped for a fair chance. Subsequent investigations by a prominent international news agency revealed a pattern at the manufacturing facility where married women were systematically excluded from employment opportunities. This practice was not officially documented but was communicated verbally to recruitment agencies responsible for hiring. The revelations sparked significant media uproar, drawing public attention to the issue. The Union Labour Ministry also took cognizance of the situation and sought a report from the state government regarding these discriminatory hiring practices. Unfortunately, such discriminatory practices are not uncommon in various parts of the world, reflecting broader issues of gender attitudes that persist in many societies. a. Discuss the ethical issues involved in the case study. b. What can be the underlying reasons for discriminatory attitudes toward hiring married women by the company? c. How can organizations promote gender equity in their hiring practices?
Deepanshu Jindal, AIR 38, 2025
Recent uproar against Foxconn (iphone manufacturers) and Huawei for their discriminatory hiring came into public knowledge.
Ethical issues in case
1. Against Right to equality Article 15,16: No discrimination on basis of gender 2. Hampers dignity of Married women 3. entrenches other forms of discrimination against married women -> Unpaid Care work -> Marital rape (Weaker sex) 4. Bad work culture of company - Not Merit but biased Hiring 5. Failure of Ministry to proactively take action (How licence given) 6. Affects economy also (37% LFPR for women) - affects revenue - affects fiscal deficit - Sovereignty ultimately
Underlying reasons
1. Company might feel that married women are less productive due to family responsibility 2. Bias that they take more leaves than unmarried women (eg) Social responsibility of family like festivals) 3. Economic cost: Maternity Benefits like 26 week pay without work to pregnant women 4. General patriarchical attitude of Men
How an organisation promote gender equity in hiring
1. Clear communication in Notification (eg) UPSC notification: We encourage women to apply in large numbers, on every page 2. Hiring process revamp: Include senior women in recruitment 3. Safety at workplace (eg) ICC not constituted in many organisation as per Section 4 of POSH 2013 4. Challenges of AI Hiring - use human face to reduce AI's gender bias (eg) Amazon shelved AI hiring due to men given preference 5. Hiring clauses should be women friendly (eg) Transport facility if late Night work 6. Infrastructural need - Creches, Social support, Women Hostels
Behai's period leaves, Karnataka's LGBTQ Hiring law can be way forward