Topper Copies

You are a young and sincere employee who has recently joined a government office as an assistant to the director of your department. Being new to the workplace, you are eager to learn and grow in your role. Your superior, the director, is an experienced and intelligent person with extensive knowledge of various departments. You respect him not just for his professional skills but also for his willingness to guide and mentor you. You have built a good rapport with him and appreciate the chance to learn from such an accomplished individual. As your relationship with your boss grows, he begins to rely on you more for work-related tasks. One day, due to ill health, he invites you to his home to help with some urgent work. When you reach his house and are about to ring the doorbell, you hear shouting from inside. Unsure of what to do, you pause for a moment but then decide to enter. Your boss greets you warmly and explains the work, but throughout, you are distracted by the sound of a woman crying in the background. Initially, you hesitate to ask about the situation, but your concern grows. Finally, you ask your boss about the noise, but his answer is vague and unsatisfactory. He quickly dismisses the matter. Although you finish the work, the unsettling environment leaves you feeling uneasy. The next day, you discreetly inquire at the office and learn more about the situation. You discover that, despite your boss's calm and professional demeanour at work, he is abusive toward his wife at home. His wife is a simple woman, not highly educated, and suffers from regular domestic violence. This information shocks you, as it conflicts with the positive image you had of him based on your interactions at work. This knowledge puts you in a difficult moral dilemma. On one hand, you respect your boss for his guidance, intelligence, and professionalism. On the other hand, you are aware of his unethical behaviour at home, which violates basic human rights and ethical principles. You struggle to reconcile the two sides of his character, finding it hard to balance your professional relationship with the awareness of his abusive actions at home. a. Under the given conditions, what are the options available to you? Evaluate each of the options listed by you. b. What course of action would you adopt and why?

Deepanshu Jindal, AIR 38, 2025

the case study reflects the divergence of personal ethics & public ethics at workplace

(beating wife v/s calm at work)

Options available & Evaluation

1. Confront the boss & file complaint

| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | No cognitive dissonance | Boss may lie about whole thing | | Standing up for what is right (Courage) | He may affect professional Career | | Virtuous Character | Boss may see it as unnecessary violation of privacy | | Protection of lady from Domestic Violence | |

2. Stay silent like others

| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Boss relation maintained | Snowball effect - Sangat ki Rangat | | Learning from Boss at professional level (good for career) | Other employees will justify & do the same at Home | | Private - Public separate | Immoral at my part |

3. File Police complaint about what I saw

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Police will investigate impartially. | Job prospects affected | | Help to lady from One Stop Centre | No locus standi | | | No employer will hire again |

Course of Action

1. Ask boss to be frank and come clean before me and others as it would affect work relation 2. Ask the lady (boss's wife) to file a complaint as such behaviour can snowball at work also 3. If still, no action, I will file complaint under One Stop Centre as it will be my moral duty 4. As far as possible, aid the social workers in investigation of Domestic Violence by giving evidence of what I saw

long term Course of Action

1. Sensitize office employees about Domestic Violence Act & POSH also 2. Display Code of Conduct Rules at prominent places (ethical behaviour - "At all times") 3. Chuppi Todo Campaign at workplace for women employees to come forward (1/3rd women face domestic violence - NFHS) 4. Uttar Pradesh Govt officers' "Bell Bajao" campaign can also be followed.