Topper Copies

Surrogate advertising — a marketing technique that promotes a product or service restricted or banned from direct advertising, such as alcohol and tobacco, by advertising a legal product like soda, water, or music CDs from the same brand — has been around for a long time. While the practice has faced criticism in the past, it has recently gained fresh attention as several famous film stars have begun endorsing these surrogate products. Public health advocates and certain sections of society are worried about this trend. They argue that when celebrities get involved, the ads become much more influential, especially among the younger audiences. These critics believe that even if the ads don't directly promote harmful products, they still make them seem more acceptable. As a result, there is a fear that such advertising could indirectly lead to higher consumption of those items, which could bring more health problems, especially among the youth. On the flip side, companies and the celebrities they work with claim they are not doing anything wrong. They point out that they are only endorsing legal products, and they have every right to advertise them. For them, this type of advertising is about keeping the brand alive and competing in a market with tight regulations. They also argue that restricting these ads could harm businesses, affecting jobs and overall economic growth. The debate continues, with each side presenting its own set of compelling arguments. a. What are the ethical concerns associated with surrogate advertising? b. Suggest a course of action that addresses the concerns of both the stakeholders involved. Justify your answer.

Deepanshu Jindal, AIR 38, 2025

Stakeholders in surrogate ads

1. Govt: revenues / job losses 2. Company: legal means / profits 3. Society: Social problems promote 4. Women: Domestic Violence: Drinking 5. Welfare: financial resources weak due to social costs rise

As per study by World bank, tobacco/drinks being ₹4 cost on health deterioration: with every ₹1 they add in revenue of govt

a. Ethical Concerns

1. Following letter of law, not spirit -> to denote such consumption 2. Moral Nihilism by actors -> "We are not promoting bad products" 3. Putting self interest above Public at large by Company (Profits) 4. Failure of Govt to control spread of Sin Goods. 5. Legal loopholes: Difficult to enforce 6. Short term perspective of actors and Company

b. Course of Action to address concerns of both stakeholders (Company, Health advocates)

1. Enforce law against surrogate advertising as Govt's duty 2. Make public aware about health effects (eg) Tobacco pack has Cancer picture 3. Make Company spend on CSR for Health at higher rate -> Nudge to reduce sin goods (eg) Hospital with revenues earned. 4. Advertising Standards Council to write guidelines on surrogate products 5. Focus on Demand Side as it will help change supply -> education institutions, promote Healthier lifestyle (eg) Fit India, Eat Right Role "Catch them young"

Promote Role Models like Sachin Tendulkar & Ronaldo

Both refused surrogate & unhealthy product Ads.