Sowmiya is a senior public servant renowned for her integrity and transparency. Currently serving as the Head of the Budget Division in the Finance Ministry, she is responsible for managing budgetary allocations critical to the government's developmental initiatives. Her department is currently organizing financial support to the states, three of which are due to go to the polls within the financial year. In this year's annual budget, the government allocated ₹9,300 crores to the National Electricity Mission (NEM), a centrally sponsored scheme aimed at providing electricity to every remaining household in the country. As of June, ₹1,775 crores had already been disbursed for this initiative. The NEM is pivotal for improving living standards and aligns with the government's broader goal of universal access to electricity. The Ministry of Commerce has been advocating for the establishment of a semiconductor fabrication unit in a southern state. This project is essential for enhancing domestic manufacturing capabilities and reducing dependency on imported semiconductors. After extensive discussions spanning nearly three years among relevant stakeholders, the Union Cabinet approved the establishment of the unit, and the process for acquiring the necessary land has commenced. In alignment with the government's policy toward a green transition, a leading Central Public Sector Enterprise (CPSE) is actively working on establishing a green hydrogen plant in a northeastern state. This initiative is crucial for promoting sustainable energy solutions and achieving the 'panchamrit' targets. The CPSE has already acquired the necessary land for the project. Following three rounds of global bidding, the project was awarded to an MNC, M/s XYZ Hydrocarbons, with the first tranche of payment scheduled for December. The Finance Ministry was asked for an additional allocation of ₹7,000 crores to support the semiconductor fabrication unit and the green hydrogen plant. It was decided to recommend re-appropriating this entire amount from the NEM allocation. The file was forwarded to the Budget Department for their comments and further processing. Upon reviewing the case file, Sowmiya recognized the potential consequences of such a reallocation. Diverting funds from the NEM could significantly delay its implementation, undermining a project that holds political significance and is frequently highlighted in political rallies. Additionally, failing to secure timely funding for the semiconductor unit and the green hydrogen plant could jeopardize these projects and lead to cost overruns. Delayed payment in an international project could send the wrong signals to MNCs about India's commitment to honoring international contracts. Such delays could harm the government's reputation and weaken investor confidence in India's growing green energy sector. Sowmiya discussed the situation with her seniors and received orders to process this politically sensitive issue expeditiously. She realized that diverting funds from the NEM could raise difficult questions for the government in Parliament. On the other hand, these projects are proposed in states where elections are to be held shortly, adding to the urgency of the matter. a. What are the ethical issues involved in re-appropriation of funds from a welfare project to the developmental projects? b. Given the need for proper utilization of public funds, discuss the options available to Sowmiya. Which option should she choose?
Deepanshu Jindal, AIR 38, 2025
The case study reflects conflicting judgements a civil servant has to take daily like welfare funding or project infrastructure (eg) CAMPA funds 80% ununitised (Both equally good - How to decide?)
a. Ethical issues in reappropriation
1. Undermines Welfare -> Social Justice as per article 39(b) & 39(c) of Constitution 2. Undermines trust of public -> going back on promise (eg) NEM to semiconductor 3. Decision paralysis -> Non Utilisation -> two equally good alternatives with exclusive use (one or other) 4. Long term interest hampered (electricity) or semiconductor/green project 5. Balancing people, profit, planet
6. Political pressure: Short term gains in polls v/s Justice & National Interests
b. Various options available to Sowmiya
1. Follow written order of superior
| Merit | Demerit | | --- | --- | | Knowledge & experience of superior is better | Ultimate responsibility is with Sowmiya | | Something is better than no decision (Utilitarianism) | Moral Abdication reflected (future decisions) |
2. Give preference to green hydrogen plant
| Merits | Demerits | | --- | --- | | Green credentials of govt, International prestige at stake, environmental cost higher | Semicon mission hampered, Electricity for all goal missed, politically pressure faced |
Course of Action: Sowmiya
1. Identify current & immediate needs of funds (not total scheme outlay, but needs right now) 2. Explore alternatives like Green bonds, Masala bonds, CSR for electricity 3. Negotiate payment terms with end users -> if anyone takes govt guarantee for time being till new funds are arranged 4. Allocate on basis -> Original purpose, Immediate payment, presence of Alternative funding
Such action would help in Objective & fair distribution without any bias