Topper Copies

What is trade enhancement and trade diversion created by Customs Union.

Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023

Trade enhancement or trade creation occurs when production and trade pattern shifts from a high-cost producer to a low-cost producer within the Customs Union.

For example, if UK joins the EU, then before joining EU, UK's exports to EU faced a tariff and hence EU found consumption of French goods cheaper.

As soon as Uk joins EU, tariffs on UK are removed and EU now buys goods from UK as they are cheaper than French goods.

[diagram: trade creation graph, axes Price and Qty; supply curve S_EU and demand curve D_EU; horizontal lines P_UK+Tariff and P_UK; points A, B on the P_UK+Tariff line and C, D on the P_UK line]

Thus, figure 1 shows that on removal of tariff, exports from UK to EU increase from AB to CD.

TRADE DIVERSION is said to occur when there is movement from a low-cost foreign producer to a high-cost member nation within the customs union.

Example, let UK be a member, buy watches from Thailand at price P_Thai. Once UK enters the EU, UK will have to impose a tariff on Thailand's watches. If P_Thai + Tariff exceeds the Price of watch in EU = P_EU, then trade diverts from Thailand to EU even if Thailand produces at a lower cost than EU.

[diagram: trade diversion graph, axes with demand curve D_UK and supply curve S_UK; horizontal lines P_Thai+Tariff, P_EU, P_Thai; points E, F on the P_Thai+Tariff line, C, D on the P_EU line, and A, B on the P_Thai line]

Thus, once Uk enters EU as a member, trade is diverted from Thailand to EU, even though Thailand is a much more efficient producer of watches than EU (as P_Thai < P_EU).

Thus, trade diversion diverts trade away from an efficient foreign producer to an inefficient member nation of the Customs Union.