Distinguish between laws and rules. Discuss the role of ethics in formulating them.
Deepanshu Jindal, AIR 38, 2025
Laws are passed by Legislatures detailing minimum standards of action. (eg) Environment Protection Act 1986
Rules are detailed provisions of how to follow intent of law (eg) EPR rules, Waste management Rules under EPA 1986 Act
| Basis | Laws | Rules | | --- | --- | --- | | Scope | Broader | Narrower | | Basis | Law is basis of Rules | Rules are made under law | | Maker | Parliament | Executive (Deptt) | | Flexibility | More Rigid than Rule | Very flexible: easily changed. |
Role of ethics in formulating them
1. Beneficence: law/Rule for benefit of all, not only few (eg) Motor Vehicle law: Good samaritan 2. Non malfecence: prevent harm to people (eg) Civil Rights Act (Untouchability) 3. Justice: ethics promote fairness in law/rule (eg) Land Rehabilitation 2013 law 4. Uphold Constitution -> ethical formation & application (eg) Due process of law (Maneka Gandhi Case)
Ethics is the bedrock of forming laws and Rules to promote Peace, Prosperity, Progress.