You are working as an Assistant Section Officer in the District Development and Panchayat Office. One day, one of your close colleagues approaches you in deep distress. She tells you that her father is suffering from a severe liver condition, and the doctors have clearly stated that he must undergo liver transplant immediately in order to survive. She shares that she has no health insurance, and the surgery would cost around Rs 15 lakh. You are aware that her husband passed away a few years ago, and that she also has a four-year-old son with special needs. Just a few weeks ago, she also lost all her savings in a digital arrest scam. As a widow from a lower middle-class family, her options are extremely limited. Although you feel deeply empathetic, you are unable to offer financial assistance, as you do not have the resources to help. A few weeks later, you enquire about her father's health. She informs you that the liver transplant surgery was successful and that her father is now recovering steadily. Relieved, you ask how she managed to arrange the funds. Hesitantly, she confides that the District Development and Panchayat Officer (DDPO) helped her. Moved by her situation, the DDPO facilitated the release of Rs 15 lakh from the fund allocated to a rural sanitation scheme. The implementation of this scheme had been put on hold for a year due to technical issues and pending site approvals. She explains that the amount was provided on the assurance of strict confidentiality and with a commitment to repay it at the earliest. She expresses deep gratitude for the DDPO's timely help, which she believes saved her father's life. She has already begun repaying the money and will continue to do so until it is all returned. a. Discuss the ethical issues involved in the case. b. Examine the behavior of DPDO from an ethical point of view. c. How would you react to the situation?
Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025
This case study involved a series of ethical dilemmas and issues due to complicated nature of human and this situation.
a) Ethical issues:
Assistant Section officer
a) Knower doer split -> Knowing this is a wrong method v/s not doing anything b) Compassion for her colleague v/s right means (Deontology) c) Dilemma for action -> not do anything to help colleague v/s duty of truth (Kant)
Women officer
a) Helping her father by any means -> compromising duty ethics b) Consequentialism of meeting ends without rightness of methods c) Wrong precedent for others -> as she took money out of a scheme
DDPO
a) Compassion by helping a widow to save her father but wrong means b) Compromised official position to extend personal favor c) Rights of rural people & need of sanitation compromised
b) Behavior of DDPO can be examined from various angles:
1. Utilitarian :- Greatest happiness of greatest number (Bentham) -> right thing by helping a women in distress 2. Deontological ethics :- Gandhiji & Kant won't agree & against Categorical imperative as means compromised 3. Virtue ethics of Aristotle -> character's integrity not allow diverting public money 4. Justice as fairness -> helped disadvantaged but at the expense of rural people 5. Transparency & accountability related to public funds not respected. 6. DDPO faced crisis of conscience and did what his heart says but duty ethics compromised 7. Could have explored other option to help -> misleading sense of justice
c) My reaction would be based on:
Values
a) Universal ethics such as honesty b) Probity -> any other value c) Objectivity related to use of public money -> transparent working d) Dharma :- uphold right means & help in a right manner
I would not have advised her to use the public funds, that too secretly even though it appears right & compassionate as she really needs the money. I would have advised to explore other options and would have extended help from private funds. I would talk to my senior as well and explain him about the dangers of slippery slope.