Topper Copies

Examine whether a Uniform Civil Code can be implemented in India, given concerns of religious pluralism and cultural diversity.

Muskan Srivastava, AIR 36, 2024

Uniform Civil Code refers to the same set of laws governing personal matters like adoption, inheritance, marriage & divorce. Presently these are governed by respective religious personal laws.

Can contradict Religious Pluralism & Cultural Differences

1. Right to Religion (fundamental right → Art 25-27) can be threatened 2. Against the idea of multiculturalism 3. Can lead to imposition of culture of majority on minority 4. Law Commission previously said it is neither needed nor desired

However, it can be implemented because

1. National integration of the country 2. Secularism as a constitutional morality upholded 3. Gender justice → all personal laws biased against women eg maintenance issues after divorce not favourable to women 4. Ease of justice system for interpretation of laws 5. Most other laws → uniform in nature eg criminal system, contract laws → they have not threatened the religion & culture

Goa and Uttarakhand have implemented UCC. A model & impact can be studied from them before implementing at the national level.