Topper Copies

India's territorial disputes after independence were not merely about borders, but also encompass issues of national identity, historical grievances, and geopolitical strategies. Discuss. (Answer in 250 words)

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

India's birth in 1947 was a bitter sweet moment as it inherited the issue of border disputes whose birth lay in colonial policies guided by greed.

[diagram: a star with five points, each naming a border dispute — Afghanistan: Durand line; Pakistan: dispute, POK, Sir Creek, due to issue with Radcliffe line; Sri Lanka: maritime dispute; 1971 → post-partition Bangladesh issue; Myanmar: ethnicity issue; China: McMahon line vs Johnson line]

Landscape of Territorial Disputes

Issues of National Identity 1. Mostly seen in North east (eg Arbitrary lines separating Kuki - Chin - Mizo) 2. Borders not water tight, culture pervasive in nature (eg Bangla identity in West Bengal and Bangladesh)

Issue of Historical grievances 3. Younghusband expedition for Tibet (1905) → grievance on unresolved nature → led to issues of row demarcation → LAC issues 4. Even the recent Nepal issue (eg Kalapani, Lipulekh) has origin in Treaty of Sugauli → associated challenges

Geopolitical Strategies 5. China and Nepal's nafarne strategies (eg China's claim on Arunachal Pradesh → strategy of boxing India in South Asia) 6. Doklam issue → as close to Siliguri corridor. 7. NJ 9842 → Siachen issue → geopolitical based on two-fold war mitigation → pincer strategy 8. Aksai Chin illegal occupation → as has water reserves.

Issues related to borders also 1. Radcliffe drew India-Pakistan boundary arbitrarily → never visited India 2. Burma part of India till 1935 → border drawing not scientific 3. Borders drawn not for convenience, but for colonial greed, strategy (eg Durand line → Napoleonic invasion issue)

True Nature of Territorial Disputes: Mix of all (geopolitics, history) 1. Idea of cultural alienation in Northeast exploited by NSCN (eg Naga Movement) 2. Sri Lanka → mix of Tamil identity, geopolitics → fisheries consumption

On similar lines, even domestic territories and state borders are based on similar issues. The birth of all disputes lies in failed policies of rulers who delineate borders without thought (eg square borders in Africa by European colonists).