Gopal is an 80-year-old man living in a remote and an underdeveloped village in a Central Indian state. He had been residing in a small mud house for years. When he came to know about the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana-Gramin (PMAY-G), he saw a glimmer of hope for a pucca house in the last phase of his life. However, the village sarpanch and panchayat secretary told him that to be eligible under the scheme, he must first demolish his existing house so that during a site inspection, no structure would be visible at the location. Subsequently, Gopal demolished his shelter and began living under a babool tree. For nearly six months, he has been staying in the open, braving harsh weather conditions. During this time, he has repeatedly visited the panchayat office but has been told that his application cannot be processed as he lacks the necessary documents. You are the officer-in-charge of implementing PMAY-G in the district. The case of Gopal reaches you through a prominent newspaper report. You personally visit him to understand the situation on the ground. After meeting him and listening to his account, you feel that he certainly needs support. Your enquiries confirm that he is truly destitute and living in a pitiable condition under the open sky. It is also established that he demolished his house based on a faulty interpretation of the scheme by panchayat officials. However, he has no documents to show that he fulfils the eligibility criteria under the scheme. Now you are in a dilemma. Including him under the scheme without the necessary documents would clearly be a violation of rules. But denying him support would be cruel and inhuman. a. Can you think of a rational way to resolve this dilemma? b. Give your reasons for it. c. What are the ethical issues involved in the above case?
Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025
This case study presents the ethical dilemma faced by officials between adhering to rule of laws and proper documentation v/s understanding spirit of law and empathetically deciding.
Stakeholders:
a) Gopal & his life b) Myself as official in charge c) Scheme of PMAY d) Panchayat e) Humanity at large f) Department
a) Rational way of solving dilemma:
1. Ensuring the poor man Gopal has a temporary shelter, not living under a Bamboo tree. 2. Inquire documentation lacking and ask the required documents to be made at the earliest 3. Ask the dept. to expedite Gopal's claim of a house without proper documents, as documents will be submitted in due time 4. Tell panchayat officials not to commit such mistakes and start their training on scheme implementation 5. A drive for documentation of poor people to avoid it in future
b) Reasons:
a) Humanitarian cause -> helping a poor man in need b) Kantian Categorical Imperative -> doing what is universally right i.e. help a needy c) Gandhian talisman -> action for the 'last man' d) Balancing procedure established by law and due process of law as per the Menka Gandhi case of the SC. e) Constitutional morality -> A21 right to live includes right to shelter f) Buddha's Karuna Doctrine -> compassionate actions g) Doctrine of double effect and primary Laws > Secondary Laws (love) as per Aquinas h) Dharma guides me to do the right thing as per my voice of conscience i) Ethical governance -> ensure public trust by working with the motto of 'Sarva Jan Hitaye'
c) Ethical issues:
1. Rule of Law :- need of proper documentation to prevent unlawful inclusion errors. 2. Empathy towards weaker section by understanding his condition 3. Right of Gopal to PMAY as per his needs but lack of documents for claims 4. Dignity being compromised for months as he was forced to live under a tree 5. Compassion towards elderlies being in question & conflict with laws.
Public servants must ensure that no one suffers due to strict implementation of laws and ensure 'Welfare State'.