Topper Copies

'The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) regime in India remains weak and is often reduced to a procedural formality.' In light of this statement, examine the key challenges in EIA implementation and suggest reforms.

Deepali Mahto, AIR 36, 2025

The Environment Protection Act 1986 introduced the Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) for review of the environmental impact of development projects.

Components of EIA and the challenge in implementation 1. Screening of the project - grade B2 industries do not require EIA (exempt) 2. Scoping - identify the key environment issues - lack of exhaustive EIA + SEA (social impact assessment) of the area 3. Base line data collection of the project - lack of credible source, disregard to indigenous knowledge 4. Public discourse - the EIA amendment year 2020 has made the gram sabha ineffective; eg nuclear/coal project in Chhattisgarh - no public discourse held 5. Monitoring of the process - lack of involvement of NGOs, BSOs in the data, feedback mechanism 6. Mitigation measures - lack of following of the Land Acquisition and Rehabilitation Act 2013 (alienation of tribal), eg Sardar Sarovar Dam

Way forward 1. Increase transparency in data collection 2. Inclusion of stakeholders, anthropologists in the EIA (Xaxa Committee) 3. Find alternative land that causes minimum impact on the tribal and environment (Gadgil Committee) - ecosensitive zones should be protected

EIA is essential for distributive justice and sustainable development.