Topper Copies

You are a Municipal Commissioner of a tier-2 city experiencing rapid urban expansion. Several high-rise residential and commercial buildings are under construction in the city to meet the growing demand for housing. One such luxury residential complex is being built, employing hundreds of daily-wage labourers, many of whom live in temporary settlements at the construction site. Late one night during the monsoon season, a large section of scaffolding and concrete slabs collapses from the upper floors of one of the under-construction buildings. Seven labourers, including two minors, die on the spot. Several others are critically injured and rushed to the hospital. The tragic incident results in public outrage, intense media scrutiny, and protests by a local NGO. The state government orders a formal inquiry and directs you to submit a report within a week. Your preliminary investigation reveals a series of irregularities. The construction material used is substandard and not in accordance with the National Building Code. Although the approved plan permits construction of fifteen floors, the builder has illegally added two extra floors. Moreover, the structure has encroached on land demarcated for a community park and a fire service lane under the city's Zonal Development Plan. These violations are not reported during site inspections conducted by the building inspector of the municipal corporation. The building clearance was granted during the tenure of your predecessor, who is not only your batchmate but also a close friend. Both of you were roommates during your training at LBSNAA. Prima facie, the case appears to involve a widespread nexus between officials of the Municipal Corporation and the builder. Your colleagues are putting pressure on you to go slow in the inquiry. Some of them suggest that holding the builder accountable could damage the city's image among investors and slow down urban development. Meanwhile, you come to know that the builder is the younger brother of a powerful minister in the state cabinet. One evening, his personal aide visits you privately. He suggests that the matter could be "mutually settled" and offers you a premium apartment worth ₹2 crore in the same residential complex. In the same breath, he hints that if the matter is not resolved swiftly in the builder's favour, someone in his office is prepared to file a complaint against you under the SC and ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. a) Discuss the ethical issues involved in the case. b) What are the options available to you in this situation? c) Explain your selected course of action.

Deepali Mahto, AIR 36, 2025

This case shows the lack of adherence to laws in the construction of the building, leading to casualties. It also shows collusive corruption.

a) Ethical issues: 1. The personal benefit (2 cr flat) vs the possible cost to your professional career. 2. Non-adherence to rules or law. 3. Shows laxity in inspection officers, indicating collusive corruption. 4. The substandard material used shows lack of procedural integrity as well as following of unethical means. 5. Shows the possible builder-politician nexus. 6. Conflict of interest of preservation of image vs preservation of your friendship. 7. Lack of regulatory oversight and encroachment of government land (community park & fire service lane) - shows the case of corruption that is widespread at the cost of the lives of the people (lacunae), against the Kantian categorical imperative.

b) Options available:

Option I: Allow the building to be made / hush the case against me. | Merit | Demerit | | --- | --- | | Personal benefit | Against the ethical code of conduct | | Preserving the friendship as well as getting in the good books of the minister | Shows lack of procedural integrity on my part; collusive corruption will keep on gaining |

Option II: Report to the seniors and request their expertise. | Merit | Demerit | | --- | --- | | Allows for diverse perspective | Shows escapism and lack of caring | | Can lead to a better solution due to their experience | The senior can also be part of the nexus |

Option III: Follow the due procedure of law and prepare the report. | Merit | Demerit | | --- | --- | | Upholds my integrity | Might lead to false cases being filed against me | | Will prevent the collusive corruption | Intra-departmental workplace hostility might happen | | The rules and law will be followed (uphold the rule of law) | | | Compensation to the labourers | |

c) The procedure that I will follow: 1. The detailed report, consisting of data, facts and investigation, can be submitted to the higher department (attachment to CM and PM) - shows my integrity as well as objectivity. 2. The compensation to the labourers who have been affected should be given. 3. The investigation report, consisting of the departmental inquiry, will be done to show accountability as well as laxity in the procedure (increases transparency). 4. Regular updates to the media to increase transparency as well as build up pressure on the politician and builder. 5. Filing the case in court with evidence, so that the due process of natural justice happens, because justice happens when the wrongdoers are punished.

By doing so, I will be able to uphold my integrity and the trust of the people in the judicial delivery.