In one of the government primary schools located in a rural block of a district, the newly appointed headmistress observed an unusual practice. The school had been preparing and serving mid-day meals separately to students belonging to different communities. Although the meals were cooked using a common gas connection, separate utensils, cooking areas, and serving arrangements had been in place for more than two decades. Students from the two communities had their food cooked and served by different cooks and ate in separate classrooms, despite attending classes together. After taking charge, the headmistress decided to discontinue this practice. She directed that food be prepared and served together for all students, using a common kitchen and utensils. However, the decision triggered backlash. A considerable number of parents across communities vehemently opposed the move and stopped sending their children to school. Consequently, attendance fell by almost 60 percent. This also raised concerns regarding the possible discontinuation of the mid-day meal scheme, withdrawal of teaching staff, and even closure of the school due to falling enrolment. The issue has attracted attention from various political and social groups attempting to further polarise the situation and serve their vested interests. Marpi Apang, the District Education Officer (DEO), has been tasked by the Deputy Commissioner's office to amicably resolve the matter at the earliest. She has also been directed to submit a detailed report along with the Action Taken Report within a fortnight. a) Identify the ethical issues involved in this case. b) What course of action should Marpi adopt and why? c) What should be the responsibilities of different social segments and agencies to create positive social ambiance for accepting such changes?
Deepali Mahto, AIR 36, 2025
Recently a village in Karnataka removed the dalit cook due to students not eating food prepared by her. This shows the strong ingrained caste mentality of Indian society.
a) The ethical issues involved: 1. The breakdown of the Constitution's given fundamental rights - Article 14, 15 (Article 17 - prohibition of untouchability). 2. Upholding of the rules by the headmistress vs the continuum of tradition. 3. The future of children in jeopardy due to the ingrained caste system - closure of school. 4. Against the inclusive and welfare justice of the Constitution (DPSP). 5. Decline of learning outcomes on hardship on families. 6. Hijacking of the conflict by political parties (moral crossing).
b) The course of action Marpi should adopt: 1. A data-driven report by consultation of the various stakeholders - this shows objectivity. 2. Talk with community leaders and engage with parents & students. 3. Increase awareness about the possible repercussions of their chosen action - appeal to conscience; use of constitutional articles, fundamental rights, to increase awareness about the illegality of their action (negative instrumentality). 4. The parents who then start accepting her idea, use them as a bridge to reopen the school - use of the MLA, MP of the area to reopen/inaugurate the school, leaving of the food by the cook of lower caste, by all the leaders. 5. Show empathy, compassion, as well as act as a role model, to inform the attitudinal change.
Long term - use of NGOs, SHGs to act as feedback and oversight mechanisms; regular visits and inspections that the practice does not come up again. This shows she is thinking with foresightedness.
c) Responsibility of the different social segments:
School, teachers, headmistress: 1. Follow the rules of the scheme. 2. Uphold the Constitution. 3. Show objectivity and neutrality in handling of such cases. 4. Uphold the DPSP, fundamental rights, and prevent discrimination.
Students and parents: 1. They should be concerned with the outcome. 2. Uphold empathy and compassion for fellow human beings. 3. Should not get influenced by caste but rather focus on national integrity.
Political parties and communities: 1. Enrich the Indian history of diversity and pluralism. 2. Develop tolerance and acceptance.
As it is said, be the change you want to see. The community and its people need to change with the new times.