Topper Copies

A rail overbridge (ROB) is being planned in the capital city of a central Indian state. The project aims to reduce traffic congestion and ease delays at railway crossings, which affect thousands of daily commuters. It had been a long-standing demand of local residents, and the government approved it to address persistent traffic bottlenecks in the area. The project is to be executed by the State Public Works Department (PWD), with a strict completion deadline of one year i.e. 31st July 2026. The PWD Minister, who is also the local MLA, is scheduled to inaugurate the project in the third week of August 2026. This is planned to take place shortly before the expected announcement of state elections. Ramesh has been selected as the project manager of this prestigious assignment on the basis of his professional competence and experience. While reviewing the approved design plans in preparation for execution, Ramesh identifies a serious flaw. The proposed alignment includes a sharp 90-degree turn, incorporated due to spatial constraints between an electrified railway line on one side and ongoing metro construction on the other. From a technical standpoint, Ramesh believes the design is unsafe. It increases the risk of vehicular accidents, especially for heavy vehicles, and may lead to long-term inconvenience for road users. Ramesh promptly raises the issue with the Chief Engineer. However, the Chief Engineer overrules the concern. He states that the General Arrangement Drawing (GAD) has already been approved by the Bridge Engineering Department, in coordination with Indian Railways. He points out that revisiting the design at this stage shall result in project delays, increased expenditure, and unwanted political attention. Subsequently, Ramesh comes to know that the contractor awarded the tender to execute the project is a close relative of the PWD Minister. He also receives unofficial communication suggesting that his promotion to Additional Chief Engineer is under active consideration, but could be jeopardised if he creates "unnecessary hurdles" in the project's timely completion. The incumbent state government is eager to complete the overbridge before the elections and present it as a major developmental achievement. This adds to the pressure on Ramesh to expedite project execution without raising further objections. Nonetheless, he remains convinced that the current design is flawed and could have grave implications for public safety if left unaddressed. Meanwhile, the bridge design has also attracted widespread public attention after being published in a leading local newspaper. Images of the sharp 90-degree turn went viral on social media, drawing criticism and ridicule. Several engineering experts have publicly flagged the alignment as a potential safety hazard, reinforcing Ramesh's concerns. a) Under the given conditions, what are the options available to Ramesh as a project manager? b) What are the ethical dilemmas being faced by Ramesh? c) What are the professional challenges likely to be faced by Ramesh and his response to overcome such challenges?

Deepali Mahto, AIR 36, 2025

This case study reflects the structural challenges that come up with a development project that was for public benefit, set against the impending state election.

a) The options available to Ramesh are:

Option I: Accept the project as it is and complete it without modification. | Merit | Demerit | | --- | --- | | The project completes on time | The project may lead to an increase in the number of accidents (deontological ethics will be affected) | | The political bosses remain happy | Loss of integrity and honesty | | Get personal promotion (Maslow's hierarchy of needs) | Injustice to the people's life and taxpayers' money |

Option II: Stop the project and proceed with modification. | Merit | Demerit | | --- | --- | | The integrity of Ramesh and the project will be maintained | Can lead to loss of promotion | | The civil servant's duty to the people will be upheld | Increases cost and time for the project | | Long-term solution shown: foresightedness | Can cause the ruling party to lose the election | | Reduces the crisis of conscience; upholds the Kantian categorical imperative, people as ends | Might cause a hostile work environment |

Option III: Raise the issue to the higher authority. | Merit | Demerit | | --- | --- | | Can get better advice due to experience | Shows escapist behaviour | | Shows dedication and responsibility | Lack of accountability and responsibility |

b) Ramesh's dilemma: 1. Personal gain vs professional duty (reporting of the lacunae). 2. Pressure from seniors and politicians. 3. Upholding the public service value (societal good - utilitarianism). 4. Accountability and responsibility of the job vs pressure from higher-ups. 5. Upholding of public trust (deontological ethics). 6. Ensuring timely completion of the project vs addressing the lacunae.

c) The professional challenges: 1. Reporting the findings to seniors - shows accountability; uphold integrity by collecting adequate data. 2. Political pressure and allegations of nepotism - report findings with adequate documentation (objectivity). 3. Lack of support from the department - uphold the MOU and SOP of such projects; report findings to the required department; follow the Weberian model and rule-based ethics.

By doing so, Ramesh will be able to do justice to his position and uphold the utilitarian principle of the larger good for a large number of people.