You are a highly motivated and principle-driven Gram Panchayat Secretary, recently posted in a large and socio-economically diverse village in a remote district. Your immediate and most critical task is the meticulous verification of beneficiaries for the 'Gramin Awas Yojana', a flagship state housing scheme aimed at providing 'pucca' (brick) houses to the genuinely impoverished and landless households. The scheme is under tight deadlines, with funds dependent on swift and accurate beneficiary selection. The District Collector has explicitly warned against any malpractices, emphasising fairness and transparency. During your diligent house-to-house verification in Ward No. 3, you discover that Mr. Inder Singh, a widely acknowledged 'strongman' whose family wields significant informal power and influence due to their landholdings and extensive local network, has been provisionally listed as an eligible beneficiary. Your on-ground assessment unequivocally reveals that Mr. Singh resides in a sprawling, multi-story 'pucca' house and his financial status is demonstrably far above the scheme's strict eligibility criteria for 'Below Poverty Line' families. When you subtly question his eligibility, Mr. Singh becomes overtly aggressive, citing his family's 'unparalleled contribution' to the village and his crucial role in mobilizing support for the ongoing, high-priority district-level 'Jal Suraksha Abhiyan' (Water Conservation Campaign), where his active cooperation is currently indispensable. He bluntly states that any attempt to remove his name would not only be seen as a grave personal insult but could also result in his family's withdrawal of crucial support from the water campaign, potentially jeopardizing the entire district's efforts, which affects thousands of farmers. He further warns that he can incite widespread local resistance against future developmental works, effectively paralyzing the Panchayat's functioning. You are keenly aware that several genuinely impoverished families, living in dilapidated shacks, have been waiting for decades for such assistance, and Mr. Singh's inclusion would directly mean one of them is unjustly excluded. Your Block Development Officer (BDO), under immense pressure to meet state targets, has privately advised you to be 'flexible' and prioritize 'overall peace and cooperation' to ensure the smooth rollout of all government schemes, hinting that challenging influential individuals like Mr. Singh might create 'unnecessary roadblocks' for your entire tenure and even impact your future postings. The village community, while silently aware of Mr. Singh's undue claim, fears openly speaking against him, making external validation of his ineligibility difficult and adding to your isolation. (a) What are the potential administrative and ethical dilemmas you face? (b) Discuss all options available to you. (c) What comprehensive course of action would you choose to adopt, providing ethical justification for your decision?
Vaibhavi Agrawal, AIR 35, 2025
The above case involves undue influence of a strongman to avail the benefits meant for poor people.
(a) Administrative and ethical dilemmas 1. Short term peace/tenure v/s long term effect on the vulnerable poor people 2. Efficient utilization of public funds v/s ensuring the deadlines for the execution is met. 3. Ensuring the due ethical duty v/s threat to the tenure. 4. Excluding the needy people by giving benefits to the rich people v/s (violating Rawls' fairness as justice) 5. Setting right precedent v/s pressure from the higher authority. 6. Threat to future development in the village due to Mr Singh's influence 7. Upholding the rule of law v/s ensuring the future developmental course and peace in the execution. 8. Internal sanction (Mill) to not execute duty faithfully v/s external sanction to delay the implementation
(b) Options available to me
| Option | Merits | Demerits | | --- | --- | --- | | Accept the strongman's offer | Peaceful execution; future development unhampered | Setting wrong precedent; will lead to exclusion of needy people | | Don't accept strongman's offer and do not give him beneficiary | Setting right precedent; justice to the poor people | Can threat my tenure; will reduce the future development of village |
(c) My course of action 1. I will choose the option 2 and not give him beneficiary as mandated by the criteria of the scheme. 2. I'll write in words regarding his wealth and hence excluded. 3. Writing to the higher authority regarding the scenario to ensure no undue pressure.
Reasons: 1. It is following rule of law and not succumbing to any strong man. 2. Internal sanction of guilt will not be there. 3. Following Kant's deontology and nishkama karma. 4. Efficient utilization of public funds - Draupadi Murmu, when serving as Jharkhand Governor, returned two tenancy Acts severely restricting tribe rights despite pressure, saying "I'll not let injustice flow from my pen."
Thus, we I'll also not succumb to the threats, rather stand by my action and not let injustice to the poor.
It's tragedy when powerful and rich feed on the schemes meant for poors, leaving the poor further vulnerable.