Topper Copies

Megha is a first-year sociology student at a reputed college in the national capital. She is originally from Tadchiroli, a tribal village in a western Indian state. Megha's family migrated to the city when she was seven years old and had not visited their village since. Though Megha has fond memories of her childhood there, she never deeply understood the customs and traditions of the region. One day, Megha expresses her wish to visit Tadchiroli. Her father agrees and asks her to inform Ratan, her paternal uncle, who still lives in the village with his family. Megha informs Ratan and travels to the village during a semester break. Upon arrival, she receives a warm welcome from Ratan and his family. Later, Ratan invites her to attend a local festival. During the event, Megha notices that her cousin Rinki is missing. Curious, she asks Ratan's wife Ratna why Rinki is not at the festival. Ratna explains that Rinki is on her period, and as per tradition, menstruating girls must stay separately in small huts built specifically for the purpose. Locally known as 'kurma ghars', they are generally located on the periphery of the village, near a river or pond. She further adds that these girls are not allowed to enter the main house or participate in any social or religious activities. Megha is taken aback. She asks whether all women follow this practice. Ratna nods and says it has been the custom for generations. Even schoolgirls stay in these huts and miss classes during their periods. Ratna admits that many in the village, including herself, never questioned the practice. The explanation unsettles Megha. She finds it hard to believe that a natural biological function leads to such exclusion. Before returning to the city, Megha observes that even educated family members seem to accept and follow these customs. The experience leaves a deep impact on her. She starts reading more about menstrual taboos and their impact on women's health, dignity, and education. As a sociology student, she recognises how such traditions are linked to patriarchy and social stigma. She begins to reflect on what she can do at her level to improve the current situation, without alienating community or disrespecting its traditions. a. Suggest a course of action Megha can take to sensitize her village community without appearing disrespectful or confrontational. b. What ethical principles and methods should guide her actions while engaging with the community? c. How is menstruation related to human rights?

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

This case study presents the deep rooted patriarchy in our society, manifesting in various forms, one being the menstrual taboos, hindering women's equality.

a) Course of action | Rationale

- Find deep cause of why such taboo persists | Evidence based action - Study the impact on women and reasons of why these taboos are wrong | To convince people using arguments - Go to the village and talk with community people about these myths | Creating awareness - Educate women about patriarchal notions of purity & pollution | Create consciousness among women - Organise public meets and use creative avenues (eg) Nukkad Nataks, posters, short dramas, poems etc | changing attitude by behavioural nudge - Promote educated dealing of menstrual days such as sanitary pads | long term solution

She can use Aristotle's holistic approach [a triangle diagram of the framework: Logos, Pathos, Ethos] to minimise resistance.

b) Ethical principles & methods:

1. Human Dignity principle of Kant -> respecting everyone's dignity irrespective of their beliefs. 2. 'Harm principle' of Mill -> not to harm others while she creates awareness 3. Teleology -> focus on 'Greatest happiness of greatest number' 4. Deontology -> ends shouldn't compromise means -> must follow right means as Gandhiji said. 5. Justice as fairness (Rawls) -> to ensure justice to women 6. 'Nyaya' & 'Dharma' Principles of Geeta (Krishna) -> ensure substantive results 7. Emotional intelligence -> to handle resistance [a pentagon diagram labelled EI at the centre, with Social skill, Motivation, Empathy, Self aware and Self regulation around it]

c) Menstruation & human Rights:

1. Right to education -> harmed as women can't go to school during periods -> frequent drop outs 2. Right to dignity -> violated as she is treated as polluted 3. Equality rights -> men treated above them 4. Hinder equal participation of women in society functions & economy 5. Right to a normal life -> she is restricted by taboos & norms 6. Equal participation in religious functions and treatment with dignity and respect just like heirs

Menstruation is a normal biological activity, must be respected in this manner (eg) Assam's celebration.