Topper Copies

Patriotism encourages ethical questioning, while nationalism often suppresses it. Discuss this statement in light of the formation of political attitudes during high-pressure national events. How can individuals develop moral attitudes that balance national interest with ethical reasoning?

Vaibhavi Agrawal, AIR 35, 2025

Patriotism refers to the love for the country, whereas nationalism often leads to excessive attachment leading to using unethical means to attain the goal of national interest.

Formation of political attitude during high-pressure national event 1. It pushes the excessive prioritisation of national interest even over the cost of other nation - Example: America's MAGA and unilateral tariffs on others. 2. It leads to grave violation of basic human rights to prevent the citizen's rights - Example: Denial of Refugee 3. It creates suppression of other community (often minority) for the greater good of greater no. (majority) - Example: Israel's war against GAZA, denying even aid facilities. 4. It violates the principles of humanitarian and universal values (Categorical imperative) - Ex: Vaccine hegemony by USA during COVID 19

Development of moral attitude that balance both 1. Balance learning from role models - Example: India's vaccine Maitri, vaccinating citizens as well as others. 2. Searching the true meaning of patriotism and nationalism (self reflection) 3. Judicious usage of media to understand. Because, ethical policy formation happens at the intersection of political attitude and moral attitude.