Topper Copies

The principle of impartiality may conflict with the need for compassion towards marginalized communities. Discuss in the context of civil services in India.

Vaibhavi Agrawal, AIR 35, 2025

Principle of impartiality refers to execution of the task without any bias against anyone. Whereas compassion towards marginalized sections demands understanding their plight and urge to act towards it.

Both of the principles are important for the civil servants. However sometimes may conflict with each other:-

1. Compassion says to relax the norms whereas impartiality suggests to not give advantage to just one, extend it to all. - Example: Relaxing documents to one vulnerable section asks for relaxation to all section. (Like must be treated alike)

However such narrow interpretation of the two values is not what is envisaged from civil servants. Both of the values must complement each other.

Example points to substantiate 1. Impartiality commands to not discriminate against anyone but compassion commands to help the vulnerable to get the required documents and avail the benefit.

Thus compassion and impartiality are inevitable values in public services as mentioned by NOLAN COMMITTEE.