You are a public representative, elected on the ticket of a political party, considered as conservative by many. Your daughter, who has returned years after studying abroad, has conveyed to you her choice of marrying a person from another community. You personally do not consider anything wrong in her choice, and convey your assent to her. You also discuss it with many among your friends and family, and inform them of a grand wedding ceremony you are planning for your daughter. However, a few days after you have shared the news of the forthcoming grand wedding with many, you are informed by your political secretary about an issue being made of the same. He informs you that there are whispers among many people in your constituency about it, and indications of a sense of unease among some prominent citizens. While most of them are enamoured by your plans for a grand wedding ceremony for your daughter, they are unhappy about the bridegroom being from another community. You also get to know through your sources in the party, that your assent to the choice of the bridegroom may lead to a denial of ticket by the high command in the forthcoming elections. You are not only an ambitious politician and a rising star in your political party but also an open-minded, loving and doting father. But howsoever much you love your daughter's freedom and choices, you do not want her decision to adversely affect your political journey. This is more so, when you had been eagerly looking forward to greater responsibilities and a higher stature in the party, given the years of hardwork you have put in, as a politician. Your daughter, on the other hand, is firm with her choice and does not want her impending grand wedding to be affected in any way. She is adamant that her wedding will not be held as a private ceremony with only close friends and family, but should be publicised in a grand way, as you had promised earlier to her. Given this situation, answer the following: (a) What are the ethical issues in the above situation? (b) What are the various options that you have, as a father and an ambitious politician? (c) What will be your course of action? Justify with proper reasoning.
Vaibhavi Agrawal, AIR 35, 2025
The above case involves the public being uncomfortable with the wedding between intercaste community. On one hand, I am open minded and affirms with my daughter's choice, on other hand, I have fear of my political career.
(a) Ethical issues involved in the above situation
| Case Points | Issues | |---|---| | Public whispering about the intercaste marriage | Highlights uneasiness in Public regarding intercaste marriage; It affects the right to marry person of your choice given in constitution (Article 21) | | Political aspirations | Ethical dilemma to choose between daughter's happiness and own political career; Hampering and compromising my daughter and her rights; Future denial of ticket leading to hampering future |
(b) Various options available to me
OPTION A: Deny the marriage and not attend it Merits: Political aspirations secured; Public will be happy Demerits: Hampers the daughter-father relationship; It will sustain the issue of intercaste marriage taboo in society.
OPTION B: Attend the marriage Merits: Happiness of daughter; Saving the relationship of daughter-father. Demerits: It can anger the public; No ticket in future
(c) My course of action will be (i) I will uphold the constitutional right of my daughter i.e. Right to marry person of your choice (Supreme Court case: Shakti Vahini v/s Union of India 2018) (ii) As a representative of public, it is my duty to guide them according to rule of law. I will try to persuade them regarding the benefits of inter caste marriage and there is nothing wrong in that. (iii) My believe in intercaste marriage can change there behaviour and they will also uphold the rights. (iv) If the party doesn't give me ticket in next election, I will take participate as independent candidate. (v) As I am a hardworking and aspiring politician, my work towards public service will not depend upon party membership. My work towards the society will guide my future.
Thus, my course of action will be to uphold the law and maintain trust by my work towards society.