Topper Copies

Traditional forms of state-led accountability, also characterised as vertical and horizontal channels of accountability, are increasingly found to be inadequate, and a myriad of multi-stakeholder and bottom-up citizen directed approaches have come to the fore, to supplement or supplant them. Discuss with illustrations.

Vaibhavi Agrawal, AIR 35, 2025

It is rightly said that if ethics is poor at the top, that behaviour is copied down through the organization. Similarly a top down approach of accountability was not enough. Example: Pressure from Political leaders affects the decision making of civil servants, hence affecting the state led accountability mechanism.

Inadequacy of state led accountability (a) No inclusion of public causing no address to public grievance. (b) State officials can be manipulated to hide the details and data (c) Also being intransparency and corruption in various department under the head of department, thus no accountability. Example: Operation West-end highlight the corruption in defense ministry

Importance of multistakeholder and bottom up citizen directed approach (a) It ensures that citizen are part of the process. Social audits have more impact upon governance. Example: Social Audit for MGNREGA holds public hearing and then report is created (b) The functioning NGOs and civil society is innovative and more effective in holding Govt. accountable Example: Environmental pressure groups (c) Multistakeholder ensures that there is less chances of hiding any data or details.

Accountability is imperative to effective function of governance. Bottom up approach is to be supplemented with state led accountability