Topper Copies

While examining the shortcomings of the land reforms in the past, elaborate what land reforms 2.0 should look like. (Answer in 250 words)

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

India planned land reforms post independence to solve 3 challenges of production, productivity, food security and fulfilling socialistic mandate of freedom struggle (Karachi resolution 1931).

What were land reforms, initially and later? 1. Abolition of Zamindari 2. Consolidation of land holding 3. Land Ceiling Act 4. Tenancy reforms

Other reforms later: - FRA, 2006 - Allowing women to inherit property - Land Acquisition Act, 2013

Examination of shortcomings 1. Land Ceiling failed in states: corruption, people transferred land to family members 2. Tenancy reforms: limited success, as poor awareness 3. Issue associated due to litigation (land is a State subject), plus Right to Property -> earlier fundamental right 4. Land reform -> focus on redistribution -> society was feudal 5. Issues with FRA, 2006: only 38% cases accepted, SC judgement about eviction -> issue with climate & environment goals (SDG 13) 6. Land Acquisition Act: high litigation, people demand release of Act -> land stays locked for years 7. Issues due to land records: land title is presumptive 8. Patriarchy: women not inheriting even after act 9. Land as a blackmarket sink, no tax on capital gains on agriculture land -> reduced to speculation

Land Reforms 2.0 should look like 1. ULPIN: Unique Land Parcel Identification Number 2. Conclusive Titling with Digital land records modernisation programme and Swamitva -> use of drones 3. Focus on land litigation policy -> fast track courts 4. Mutation of land -> quick redressal -> use land for productivity purpose 5. Integrated approach to land reforms -> make a balance

6. Land Pooling Scheme: private sector makes land clusters for industrialisation (PPP mode) 7. Forest policy: 33% forest cover target -> identify areas -> use agroforestry, but no greenwashing 8. Tribal lands: rights under FRA 2006 9. Land as a solution to naxalism (eg Op Baagi in early days; development induced displacement) 10. Relook at compulsory acquisition

Land is the most integral asset as India has 4% land, 17% population. Thus focus on efficient, sustainable use.